Actually the real question is why you have not yet been able to develop and implement a consistently profitable trading plan? Whether or not I even trade at all is irrelevant.
jeeze man...i'll just post one time here..so u can go on lining up people. i have more pnl posts than anyone here on et...some have posted larger of course..but no one has been more consistent than me since 2008. i never ever go in to how i do it and rarely what i trade. there is a reason of course...its mine and i want as little competition as possible. what i do like to show is that trading can make one a living.. you and your other guru people imo are so FOS its nutz. but carry on anyway.
That's nice. But one doesn't make a living by trading through following others' PnL postings but rather by putting together and implementing a consistently profitable trading plan.
Your trading results are very relevant in light of your role as a guru and the way you talk and conduct yourself in this thread. You can still provide insights and tell us about what you've learned from your losses as long as you're honest about where you're at, but it's dishonest to pretend that you're a successful trader and continue leading people on.
None of which has anything to do with your inability to develop and implement a consistently profitable trading plan.