Tradingschools.org is reviewing from a different angle. Emmett posts a review full of context that he might update later on if things change enough. What I'm doing is tracking performance. So, if Emmett and I both reviewed Vanguard he would write about their products and customer service where I would compare returns of their investments to the S&P.
So is Emmet, just most of the time they don't provide it for him. But he always asks for evidence and track record.
Ok, so a little more than 5 months later and I've launched! I'm excited to hear any feedback you have: www.thetradebarometer.com
Are you still looking for a copy of that book Mark? If so, PM me a mailing address and I'll send it to you. It's spiral bound, type-writer quality font, and nothing in it that looks that interesting... but if you want it, it's yours.