IMO you gotta learn to trade with a macro trend (wind in your sails sorta speak). Which method you use becomes a secondary factor in that case. Reward vs risk is a primary concern. You will always struggle to have a consistently high strike rate (streaks will come & go), that's why it's so important to have reward at least x2 the risk.
iamnewuser911, you haven't tried this: https://www.elitetrader.com/et/threads/simple-es-1min-chart-trading.304732/
Technical indicators can improve your odds, but they were never meant to be perfect. They can send out wrong signals from time to time. However, when you are experienced in their use and good interpretation can lead to a level of consistency that can translate into net gains and profits in the long term
Technical analysis can only tell you were the underlying has been historically. The interpretation of the historical artifacts will skew your success vs failure, we each take a side. The future is anyone's guess, for every buyer there is a seller. IMHO If it worked 50% of the time we'd be rich. There is something to be said about market neutral strategy for the long run, half the battle is capital preservation and beating the indexes consistently.