This is a really weird thread. Combination of the OP's topic, guru bashing, TA hatin', TA lovin', bravado and arrogance, some common sense mixed in with allot of stupidity and even some live calls. Go team!
@Datum congrats. you have really done a more than marvellous job of collection of tradeable ideas in printed formation, only from nodoji's original ideas and no others'? this is just a great beginning, and it could be very beneficial for any aspiring traders to be, to start out trying to test one concept at a time, or a combination of two or three or more concepts of interest; on just one product AND one time frame, like the common 5 min; to find out the applicabilities and viabilities of whatever concepts appeared to be of interest to the aspiring traders to be. it would be very interesting to see and verify any or a combination of, or all of these concepts on a live simm here at et for all to scrutinize and enjoy to the fullest. and i'll bet, if put on youtube too, concurrently, it would generate a favorable rating to propel et to the fore front of its peers, if not more. datum, go at it. pick a favorable product of your choice and run with it starting with the evening session, if you like. or tomorrow day session, whichever suits your trading styles and/or time frame best. i'll drop in occasionally with the rest of the trading world to enjoy your live show in action, right here on et. my best wishes to you and anyone who wishes to apply the same to test out another product of your personal interests. now et would have something really interesting for all aspiring traders including seasoned traders to watch, learn, compare, test and retest; whatever concepts or ideas.... in terms of profitability and sustainability. best trading to all, with perhaps, excitement in the air! with due respect to all.
yes, this is just a microscopic trading community of the real trading exchanges of the trading world. you can see all sorts of traders, profitable or not, in action right here at et. so watch, pick and choose, learn and enjoy to the fullest but at your own risks and all. cheers.
That's harsh, Debit. We are talking about folks money and more importantly time here. Its sad to see such effort put into nebulous ideas. Its easy to get the money back, but time is gone forever. Frankly, it makes me ill to see this type of effort be put into this crap. Guys going on 5 years and still don't get its the flawed system and not themselves. But whatever, i have tried to tell the truth. surf
Is there a reason why you can't do that now by yourself ? Seriously, wouldn't you take the results more serious if you tested the concepts yourself ? I'm just curious because most traders here at ET doesn't trust what others have to say about what works and doesn't work. They demand access to "all" info (don't leave out one piece) so that they can study, test and trade it themselves even though the user is discretionary (not automated).
i also agree with you wholeheartedly, trading comrade, and ridiculously so that our aspiring comrades.... ....They demand access to "all" info (don't leave out one piece) so that they can study, test and trade it themselves even though the user is discretionary.... most truly are overwhelmingly demanding.... without ever giving anything back too....! Right? ------------------------------------ AND DO YOU, YOURSELF--WRBTRADER, really really wants my humbled self to.... ....Seriously, wouldn't you take the results more serious if you tested the concepts yourself ? DO U REALLY WANT ME TO, TRADING COMRADE, to prove it once and for all....? tell me honestly, if you really do? best trading for all. ---------------------------------- and you guys out there, pls be considerate some, K? nobody is paying anybody here, remember? we are all here by our own choices, wisely or poorly; to hopefully learn something worth while, sometimes, from someones who are generous enough to hint and show, here and there, some roadmaps to trading profitably and sustainably, WITHOUT ANY COMPENSATION. --------------------------------- comrade, do u still want to see me walk the walk and perhaps even dance the dance too.... pls?
No...I don't want to see you dance. :eek: Joking aside, you don't have to prove anything to me. Its others (you know who they are) that will request proof or verification.
40 is a trader many of us would love to see ...but 40 is no longer on here. Fortydraws is an anomaly with legendary trading skills. Despite what kp says ...40d made a tremendous effort to help others. 40's posting history has multiple gaps where he left ET as a direct result of kp's complaining. Kp's interaction with another legendary anomaly was similarly negative, controversial and a prelude to the scenario which resulted in the loss of 2 great ....constructive thinkers. Kp didn't know better and still believes his efforts root out additional proprietary stuff he needs. He needs more than is offered because he doesn't work thru what's provided. He says he does but he consistently misses simple things which are easily reverse engineered. Like limit entry with 5pt stoploss irrefutably recurring. Including cases on both sides of the exact delineating tick. Observing timestamp differentials between when 40 provided data and how quickly afterward kp replied ...imo kp ignored what 40 offered in favor of a rush to complain the data was insufficient. Forgive and ignore but never forget. Remind others. Kp can't fathom he's responsible for this loss. This denial combined with his claim brooks and all these great thinkers methods aren't good enough enables him to persist in avoiding the work that must be done to learn any new method. Others on this thread (and Q3D's ----- Al Brooks – Al Crooks, Charlatan thread) have negative intentions from the get go. Resentment and a desire to destroy brooks and everything he stands for. In some cases these antagonists (at least in my opinion, the way I read them) ...are intent on destroying everything good or constructive.
Yeah..... that GIF of NoDoji postings is something else. But you have to admit.... have you heard a more compelling success story? I also put much time into reading forum gurus in the past so am familiar with it. I think it goes like this.......... Housewife with no trading experience becomes star daytrader and within a year or so is making life changing amounts of money. Never blew out an account and only ever had a few losing months. In under 2 years is making over 100k per year per contract traded, almost never has a losing day, hits the daily profit goal almost every day, is actively mentoring others, and advertising the viability of making six figs a year as a 1-lot daytrader. It's easy to see why so many become mesmerized. it is an icredible tale, that is for sure!
When I read posts like this, it reminds me why I do not frequent this site or post often. The negative attitudes from those frustrated traders who I suppose cannot get themselves trading profitably is like a disease gone wild. There are plenty of good ideas shared by some traders here if most of you were not too lazy to evaluate and test them for yourself. Instead, you want a fully developed trading plan, someone to train you on it, and then someone to trade live with you on it until you are making money hand over fist. It reminds me of those little souls who need Pampers and Gerber. I have traded with NoDoji and I can tell you it is real. If you choose not to believe it, so be it. Take away one thing though.. It is possible to do what you have quoted above. Too bad most of you choose not to believe it can be done and therefore will never achieve it. Like Confucius said: “The Man who says he can, and the man who says he can not.. Are both correct” Peace and out. Wolf