how to understand Al Brooks

Discussion in 'Educational Resources' started by padutrader, Apr 24, 2018.

  1. #71     Apr 25, 2018
    Sprout, Xela and fordewind like this.
  2. volpri

    volpri

    LOL

    1802AA14-216B-443A-801A-9A3D7F072F09.jpeg
     
    #72     Apr 25, 2018
  3. volpri

    volpri

    #73     Apr 25, 2018
  4. #74     Apr 25, 2018
  5. Sure, bro. Let's get this straight. First the guy writes an incomprehensible book. And then, recognizing that he left most (all?) readers holding the bag, he sets out to clarify and simplify his thinking by...writing three more books for an additional 1,680 pages. How's that for clarity and simplicity? Because, if I remember correctly, the original rationale for his writing 3 more books was to make better sense of his first one.

    Welcome to the scientology of trading.
     
    Last edited: Apr 25, 2018
    #75     Apr 25, 2018
    padutrader likes this.
  6. speedo

    speedo

    Jeez, you'd think Al was selling "youth serum" to seniors over the phone. I've know Al for a long time, we traded together for the better part of a year in a small chat environment. I'v never seen his P&L nor do I care to but I can say that at the time he had a solid trade plan and he took his signals and observed the rules of the plan. The guy is smart, hard working, disciplined and focused. We went in different directions technically in about 2003 but remain in periodic touch.

    He sent me a copy of his first book and like most of you, found it a hot mess but I do know first hand that a great deal of effort went into it's making. Look, a number of folks have found his work and ideas instrumental to their success, why not respect that. If you don't like what he's done, then leave it alone. The guy is the furthest thing from a con man.
     
    #76     Apr 25, 2018
    NQurious, Joe6Pack, volpri and 3 others like this.
  7. You have a point. But this is a forum for the exchange of ideas and opinions. I readily support and defend some books, and I criticize others. Why is a criticism less valid than an endorsement? Why can his supporters be more repetitive than his detractors? I don't know the man. I never met him. He might be a good guy; he might be brilliant. But I wouldn't know it from what I have read in his book. And it is his (first) book I am judging, not the man.

    And that focus of which you speak? Why can I not find it anywhere in his book? However hardworking he may be, as far as his writing is concerned, he phoned it in. So why should I give his book more consideration than he did?
     
    #77     Apr 25, 2018
  8. speedo

    speedo

    Fred, you should have your own investigative TV show. You would be one of those dogged reporters rooting out evil and injustice. :D
     
    #78     Apr 25, 2018
    NQurious likes this.
  9. Really? I think I'd make a better living selling pompoms on this thread. :D
     
    #79     Apr 25, 2018
    lcranston and lawrence-lugar like this.
  10. truetype

    truetype

    If he was indeed a "very successful" eye surgeon, he would have saved millions from his hefty annual income and could easily support himself clipping muni-bond coupons. The fact that he's able to pay his bills says nothing about his short-term trading prowess.
     
    #80     Apr 25, 2018