How much do day traders make

Discussion in 'Trading' started by newdog, Jan 27, 2017.

  1. #171     Jan 30, 2017
    rajesheck likes this.
  2. 1% return each day?

    Starting with 1k account, you become Billionaire in less than 6 year if you compound your return.

    You must be one of the anonymous billionaire in ET.

    Btw, why you still collect the social welfare check to fund your forex micro account with bucket shop?
     
    Last edited: Jan 30, 2017
    #172     Jan 30, 2017
    systematictrader likes this.
  3. hahahahahahaha
     
    #173     Jan 30, 2017
  4. 1% per day in day trading on options is not a big deal. Real challenge is "consistency". :)

    While manual trading, becoming billionaire may not be possible as there is a limit to the investment based on the volume of the script being traded beyond which compounding stops and settles to a standard kind of income. And I am not sure about the efficiency of automated trading when compared to manual trading.
     
    #174     Jan 30, 2017
  5. algofy

    algofy

    Gotta work bucket shop into every post?
     
    #175     Jan 30, 2017
  6. Vindago

    Vindago

    Yeah, you are all right, I was joking... what a lough 1% a day... still, wouldn't that be nice if you could do it?

    hahahaha!
     
    #176     Jan 31, 2017
  7. Mtrader

    Mtrader

    I always have problems with this kind of statements as there is a lot of essential information missing to make this conclusion a correct one. The statement starts from the conclusion and manipulates the information backwards to arrive at the pre-defined conclusion.

    Some of the many missing things:
    • What is he trading? If he trades the ES he will need each time enough profit to add 1 contract on margin. Suppose the margin he uses is 1K, then he will need to trade 100 days before he can add 1 contract. But you probable calculate a compounding rate of 1% each day which leads to $2,704.81 whereas reality will be only $2,000. SO after 100 days there is already a big mistake in your calculation. Continue this error for 6 years and the difference between theoretical return and reality is huge.
    • When reaching 1 billion he should trade 1 million contracts at a time if he does 1 trade a day. Will this be possible? Even trading 10% of that, so 100,000 contracts will be a problem. Which broker will accept this kind of position and if you find one, what will be the margin he requires? Surely not 1K.
    • Maybe he is not interested in eternal compounding and is happy with daily 100-500 contract positions. In that case he will indeed make 1% a day but never be a billionaire. So your conclusion is not correct in this case.
    • Renaissance Technologies has a much smaller return than 1% a day and they refused already many years ago new clients and made huge cash payments to lower the amount of money they trade. They were not able to manage the money anymore. Although they are trading 24/7 all the markets in the world with a team of dozens of traders. So even for them your compounded return logic makes no sense.
    Depending on the assumptions you make, realistic or not, you can proof anything.

    I make more than 1% average a day, consistently and over a long period of time. But I am not a billionaire and will never be one as I limit the amount of money, and the time spend, that I use for trading. According to you that is impossible because by definition I should be a billionaire. Reality is not black or white. There are many grades of gray between these two extremes. Many parameters can change and result in a totally different outcome.

    I do agree that making consistent profits is not easy, but a bit of honesty would not harm a real correct discussion. And indeed, don't believe everything what people post here. Do some critical thinking.
     
    #177     Jan 31, 2017
    Xela and rajesheck like this.
  8. His point is that you'd be insanely rich in 6 years' time compounding 1% daily, even if you haven't made a billion dollars by then.

    Nobody can make 1% daily without fail, not even renaissance tech, this is why they have years in which they "only" made ~20%. There will be bad days, weeks and even years where even the best traders make very little money or a loss.
     
    #178     Jan 31, 2017
  9. Mtrader

    Mtrader

    First read correctly what I wrote. You clearly don't understand (or don't want to) my posting.
    You need much more information to make a statement that is valid. I named some of the missing parameters.

    I will give you a very simple example:
    • X daytrades the ES.
    • X trades 20 contracts and makes more than 1% every day ON AVERAGE, so not every day 1%, but the final result after 1 year averages more than 1% per day. So about 250-300% a year.
    • X always trades 20 contracts, so NO COMPOUNDING. That's his free choice.
    • X makes 1% ON AVERAGE which means that he makes 10$ per day per contract (1% on 1k margin). So he makes less then 1 TICK a day. That is impossible for you???
    • X will never be rich, although X does make average more than 1% a day. That proofs that your statement is wrong.
    According to you this is impossible, because X should be rich. Tell me what is wrong and proof me that X does not make 1% a day ON AVERAGE. The fact that he is not rich is no proof because you make own assumptions about how and what he should trade.

    Don't compare daytrading 20 contracts with Renaissance. It is normal that they can not make the return a small daytrader can make on a small position.

    Show me the complete detailed calculation of how rich I should be if I say that I make 1% a day on average. I will then show you all the mistakes you made in your calculation.

    Let me guess: you will not show these detailed calculations? Proof your statement and I will proof that it is wrong. Should not be difficult.
     
    #179     Jan 31, 2017
    Vindago and Xela like this.
  10. You can ...relatively...easily make much more than 1% a day with options o_O:p ...that's being very modest.

    I don't want to throw any numbers around..because some may start to claim I'm full of stuff. and why i'm not a Billionaire yet yadda yadda with a perfect storm of compounding.

    I personally don't have to be rich. I live very modestly and simple and frugal.
    If I can make a certain amount daily/weekly/monthly/yearly that I don't have to work a regular job...I'm the happiest man on earth.
     
    Last edited: Jan 31, 2017
    #180     Jan 31, 2017
    Xela, Hooti, rajesheck and 2 others like this.