I meant the decade of the 2000's. Unfortunately the graph doesn't provide enough detail to confirm whether that bottom was in 2002 or 2009. In either case, I find it hard to believe that the 10 year average PE was 15 at the bottom. 7-10 sounds more reasonable. In 2009, when we hit the bottom, SPX earnings were like 70 dollars/share and that was the recessionary earnings. The 10 year average would have been higher than that.