Gaining Muscle and Losing Fat (2015)

Discussion in 'Health and Fitness' started by Baron, Jun 30, 2015.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. fhl

    fhl

    Yeah, right Fred.
    You've spent this whole thread saying less is more and posting article after article trying to prove that low volume provides for gains as well as high volume, including for old folks like Clarence Bass, who've trained for decades, just like yourself. Then you come off with how it doesn't apply to you? If you're so finely tuned that you couldn't possibly attain any gains without 'working yourself into the ground', then why are you so interested in all the less is more stuff? Less is not more for you. This thread is not about getting back to your baseline. It's about gains. Thread title and all? So try to stay on topic, alright smartass? It's been on topic until you tried to take it in another direction. I don't appreciate that. Do better.
     
    #671     May 13, 2016
  2. Are you obtuse, or are you just enjoying yourself? Despite my trying to make myself clear to you in good faith, you chose to misinterpret pretty much everything I wrote because you evidently have an ax to grind. Perhaps now would be a good time for another one of your anti-Buffett dietary updates, Dick.

    [​IMG]
     
    Last edited: May 14, 2016
    #672     May 14, 2016
  3. An interesting exchange on volume and frequency:

    http://www.exrx.net/Questions/TrainingFrequency.html

    Perhaps somewhat extreme, even for my own newly-acquired taste for low volume & frequency, but it does serve as something of a reminder to not just mindlessly accept conventional wisdom broscience at face value.
     
    Last edited: May 16, 2016
    #673     May 16, 2016
  4. I am inclined to believe once muscle strength and tone have been developed that a person would not lose strength or tone with less frequency. I still maintain that more frequency is what you need up front when trying to get yourself into shape. I also believe that isolation exercises are a waste of time and strength during this beginning phase. That, and a clean diet matters, a lot.
     
    #674     May 16, 2016
  5. You'll note, however, that he claimed to have gotten both stronger and bigger when he reduced his frequency:

    "When I first tried this, I was worried about losing the minuscule gains I had managed to achieve with traditional higher frequency training. But after I got over this initial fear and gave it a try, my strength and muscle gains were tremendous. I challenge anyone to give it a try."

    Relatively speaking, I do agree that higher frequency is better for a beginner than when he becomes more experienced, because he will not initially be able to exert the kind of intensity than will later require greater recovery time. As for isolation exercises, I'm not really sure what they bring to the table regardless of a person's training age.
     
    Last edited: May 16, 2016
    #675     May 16, 2016
  6. Couple of things to report. On Sunday, which was a deadlift, squat day, wall ball warm up day. I decided to really concentrate on form and slow down my reps. Didn't add any weight at all and didn't do any more reps or sets than usual. Woke up yesterday morning and holy crap, was sore and stiff like I was a newbee.
    Monday was a rest day. Today was upper body weight day. I always do a 15 minute cardio warm up before this routine. Nothing crazy, just a decent pace on an elliptical. Just a mild sweat going. Today I decided no warm up other than my normal 10 minutes of stretching I do before every workout. 10 minutes in. Not breaking a sweat. 20 minutes in. Nothing, I'm powering through. 30 minutes in. Not so much as a glisten on my skin. Feel great. 35 minutes and I'm standing there like, okay that's it. Routine is finished and I don't feel like I've had much of a workout at all. Did everything I normally do. Can it be that the 15 minutes of mild, I emphasize mild cardio warm up is taking that much out of me?
     
    #676     May 17, 2016
  7. wjk

    wjk

    I've been reading up on this. I didn't realize there was so much debate. Rehab seems to be the most common answer. Targeting individual groups seems a more limited reason, though in a few muscle groups, effective...especially in more advanced lifters who know how to apply it as a supplement to their compound exercises with result varying from lifter to lifter. Pre-exhaustion comes up, and I would add, if you want to train around certain injuries, there may be no choice but to use isolation. In general, compound lifting is king. I didn't link the articles I read. They are abundant on the web.

    I've recently added an extra day of recovery between workout days (either after 2 consecutive or 3 consecutive workout days) and I'm very happy with the results: more strength in the gym on workout days. Working fairly light on the weights with moderate reps as I've had two setbacks this year...broken transportation cost me a month (I have a nice setup here, but can't get to it until I get rid of some junk) and then the flu cost me another two weeks just a month later. Back in business, now, though. Doing mostly compounds currently. Feels good to be back in the gym.

    Anyone here utilizing the Mediterranean style diet, regardless of fasting?
     
    Last edited: May 17, 2016
    #677     May 17, 2016
  8. Good question. Although I know some people who start their workout with light cardio as a warm up, I never do. I don't want anything to compromise my lifting routine, so I leave the cardio for later. I used to stretch for several minutes before my workout, but after reading Body By Science I decided to leave it for the end, after cardio. In my own case, now as soon as I enter the gym, I do 2 light warm up sets for legs, which is the first muscle group I address, and go from there. I find it suits me. I feel strong and energized at the outset after the 2 warm up sets, and the stretching feels good at the end of the routine. I'd be curious to know how others here sequence their routine.

    CaptainO, do you find that you prefer to start your routine without a cardio warm up? And if you feel you didn't have "much of a workout at all," perhaps you might wish to consider increasing the intensity a bit. Just a thought.

    I think you're on to something. :)
     
    Last edited: May 17, 2016
    #678     May 17, 2016
    CaptainObvious likes this.
  9. #679     May 17, 2016
  10. Glad to hear you're back in business. And, yes, what a difference a day makes, eh? I find that I have more energy ever since I added an additional recovery day, which took my routine from 2x a week to 3x every 2 weeks, and I really look forward to the next workout.

    You will recall the 2-part interview of bodybuilder Gordon LaVelle, which I posted recently in this thread. In one of his books he wrote this about working out and competitive bodybuilders:

    "Although it has been proven that weight-training workouts need not be long or frequent to be optimally effective, this fact is often incongruent with the mentality that drives men to build extremely muscular physiques."

    And he was talking about guys who take steroids, which also aids in recovery. So you can imagine that the point is even more applicable to natural, slightly more vintage guys like us.
     
    #680     May 17, 2016
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.