FX Majors: No trolling.

Discussion in 'Forex' started by DepthTrade, Aug 4, 2009.


  1. I don't understand, could you explain please, thanks........


    You closed trades and then 2 minutes later re-opened them in the same direction, paying Oanda's weekend spreads of 10 pips. Why would you do that?

    You just spent 40 pips for absolutely nothing!

    [​IMG]


    Also your USD/JPY exit was not posted in real-time. If you exited it at the same time as the others it would have been closed at 97.61 5 not 95.90 4, a loss of 298.1 pips not 127 pips, making a total loss of 601 pips -1.94%

    It's a mystery why anyone would allow profitable positions to turn so negative, and then spend 40 pips closing them and re-opening them two minutes later, could you explain?
     
    #21     Aug 9, 2009
  2. DepthTrade

    DepthTrade

    Have exited positions at the following prices.


    Gbp/usd: -38.3 pips

    Usd/cad: -61.5 pips

    Usd/chf: -38.8 pips

    Usd/jpy: -27.1



    Classic FX
    start date 02/08/09
    Closed trades,
    -595.6 pips
    -1.91%

    :)
     
    #22     Aug 11, 2009
  3. Could you please indicate the exit prices?
     
    #23     Aug 11, 2009
  4. Putz

    Putz

    I am the one who gave Paul $1,000.00 to trade. I believed the guy was honest and I'm a firm believer that everybody needs a break once in a while. I monitored the trades and posted them on Moneytec.

    I will admit that I did get all my money back with a minute profit. In my opinion, I believe Paul is basically honest but he has a far higher opinion of his trading than what he is capable of.

    A couple of days ago, I sent him an email telling him to stop saying lies about what happened between us. He responded in typical rude, obnoxious and arrogant manner. I'm tired of his threats, childish tantrums and blatant lies.

    If anybody is considering investing with Paul / Depth Trade, please PM me. I don't want this to turn into a childish mudslinging battle. I am willing to share my experience and documented information.

    Good trading to all.
    Putz
     
    #24     Aug 11, 2009
  5. Paul stated that the 20% draw-down was the result of you insistence that he buy spot gold in the account. Obviously it's ridiculous, but you can confirm or deny it here.

    http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&postid=2528128#post2528128
     
    #25     Aug 11, 2009
  6. Putz

    Putz

    Hi Atticus

    I never told Paul to buy any metals of any form. He was in control of what was bought and what was sold. I had no control of the account. I needed his authority to be able to get my funds back.

    Putz
     
    #26     Aug 12, 2009
  7. Thanks for clarifying.
     
    #27     Aug 12, 2009
  8. Hi Putz

    Thanks for putting us in the picture.

    It seems Paul Chaney / Depth Trade / Pablo is trying to do the same on this forum as he's tried to do on other forums. As he's soliciting for funds I think it's important for potential investors to know what they would be letting themselves in for!
     
    #28     Aug 12, 2009
  9. Just to keep it real......

    The prices at the time he posted to say the trades were closed:

    GBP/USD 1.6480 -209 pips
    USD/CAD 1.1010 -202 pips
    USD/CHF 1.0812 -6 pips
    USD/JPY 95.98 +153 pips

    start date 2nd August 2009
    Closed trades:
    -865 pips
    -2.78%
     
    #29     Aug 12, 2009
  10. DepthTrade

    DepthTrade

    Have entered following positions.



    Aud/usd: short 0.8321

    Gbp/usd: short 1.6537



    Classic FX
    start date 02/08/09
    Closed trades,
    -595.6 pips
    -1.91%
    :)
     
    #30     Aug 15, 2009