Forex? Discussion

i have compared it to other brokers with whom i have accounts.
if you represent volume by a graph and draw this graph using data from different sources, the SHAPE of the graph will be the same.

Absolute volume may vary widely but relative volume will be the same.

Why do prices from all brokers align? because if it did not align, arbitrage would take place, and in fact there is software that is available that claims to do just this.

What i am trying to say is that we are comparing volume between bars and if we compare bars in the same broker, we will get an idea whether volume is normal or not normal for the price movement in question.

All this only pertains to spot forex.


There are others like Wyckoff Gavin Holmes and Anna Coulman who say the same thing:Anna has written a book on how to trade VPA with forex

 

Bullshit. I also love how you created a new class of trader- the volume arb trader

 

can i see your qualification for this statement when i am making money using this what makes you better than me?
volume arb? you cannot arbitrage Price without adding volume so who is bull shitting

 

I wonder what holy grail idea you will insist works next week.

 

i do not use one technique they all work

but this is not about me or you

it is about forex spot and volume and whether it can be used

i am using volume in forex spot and it has made me profitable.

i am not going to bother to prove it

you can take this information and do what you want to do with it

 

Define profitable

 

this is all that matter

 

Some writeup from ET are useful, educational and enlightening.

Some writeup are simply shitty and garbage.

We need to have discerning eyes when reading those writeup.

 

why? i am not bothered whether anyone believes it or not

if they believe forex volume is genuine let them use it -i use it

 

how can you prove anything without disclosing your real name.