General Topics
Technical Topics
Brokerage Firms
Community Lounge
Site Support

# Finally, Fibonacci in Perspective

Discussion in 'Technical Analysis' started by Thunderdog, Nov 12, 2003.

1. ### Thunderdog

The following text is from today's column in Innerworth. Since I could not say it any better myself, I just copied and pasted it for your reading pleasure.

The Golden Mean: Real Trading Phenomenon or Just Wishful Thinking?

If you've spent any time around trading, you've probably run into the Golden Mean. You may have seen it represented as Fibonacci lines on a price chart. The Fibonacci sequence is a string of numbers in which two consecutive numbers are added together to produce the third, for example, 1, 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13, 21, 34, 55, and so on. Some traders use ratios derived from the Fibonacci number series to define key support and resistance levels, often with the belief that such estimates are more "natural" because they are based on the Fibonacci sequence. Fibonacci claimed that consistent patterns could be found in what appeared to be random numbers. Subsequent followers of Fibonacci extended his theory to the trading of futures and stocks as they attempted to find patterns in random price activity. But are there "natural and pristine" patterns in the seemingly random movements of prices, or is it just wishful thinking?

One way of calculating the Golden Mean Ratio is to add two random numbers together. That result is then added to the sum. After eight reverberations, one can divide the former number into the latter and find a definable pattern, which is represented mathematically as 0.618 or its reciprocal, 1.618. This Golden Mean is thought to reside in the most beautiful architecture, music and art. It is commonly found in nature in the structure of many of the most beautiful flowers, animals, and seashells. Greek philosophers and mathematicians saw the Golden Mean as significant because it illustrated balance in nature, the arts, and even the human body. It was the epitome of balance-the perfect shape â¦ the most pleasing vision.

In the natural world, it is amazing how consistent patterns abound, but when it comes to human behavior, social scientists have long known that such consistencies are rare and almost non-existent. And what is trading? It is human behavior. It's not a natural phenomenon, but made up by humans. It's not perfect. It's not pristine. It is in disarray and unpredictable. To be a successful trader, one must accept the uncertainty of human behavior and engage in the daunting task of finding consistency where there is little.

2. ### Avalanche

Dude, its a free newsletter, get a grip.

3. ### Thunderdog

My dear IGNORANT friend,

It is not plagiarism, since I am not taking credit for the text. Rather, I am quoting it. I have neither a paid subscription with Innerworth nor an ownership interest in it. What you have read is available for free. I am passing on free information. Any other questions? If not, then go keep a watchful eye on your neighbors for suspicious or subversive activity.

4. ### inandlong

LOL! That's funny.

5. ### mojo59

I am a subscriber to Innerworth and was surprised to read this article. They usually aren't so judgemental and especially regarding a trading method the writer seems to know nothing about. I'm sure in the writer's mind it is acceptable to use lagging indicators based on past price action because they are mechanical and used by most traders.

Joe Dinapoli in his book, "Trading With Dinapoli Levels, the Practical Application of fibonacci Analysis" set out a method of trading fibonacci levels and also incorporating popular lagging indicators for help in determining trend and entry/exit. This man's background is in Electrical Engineering and Economics. Not exactly pie in the sky stuff. The bottom line is that the more you trade utilizing fib levels properly, the more you see it working.

Innerworth reminds me of those in the fundamentals camp laughing at technical traders. I think no two traders are alike and if you find something that works, isn't that what all of this is about?

6. ### Specul8r

Was this guy serious? If so, then he is a moron. And if he is a moron - what does it make you for rehashing such jibber-jabber...

Get a clue man...

7. ### Thunderdog

Actually, I read the Innerworth column occasionally and, unless I am mistaken, it seems to focus more on the technical side of trading rather than the fundamental. Sorry, but your trying to connect the dots between electrical engineering & economics, and Fibonacci numbers is something of a stretch in my opinion. Forgive me, but I just happen to share the writer's opinion that Fibonacci numbers are a crutch. You may wish to take it up with him.

Regards,

Thunderdog

8. ### Thunderdog

My dear Specul8r,

If you actually read the column as I copied and pasted it, then you would see that the writer of that column believes that Fibonacci numbers give traders a false sense of reassurance in trading; essentially, that such numbers are a crutch. I just happen to share that view and, from what I gather by your comments, however rude, so do you. And yet, we seem to be at odds. Is it because you did not read the whole column before you decided to criticize it? If so, that is unfortunate. Perhaps, if you have an attention deficit issue, you may wish to have someone else read it for you and paraphrase it in simpler terms for your benefit. Then you may wish to come back and be insulting. Hope that helps.

Regards,

Thunderdog

9. ### pisspotpete

This guy sounds an awful lot like Scientist. C'mon Sci, fess up!

10. ### Specul8r

Thunder,

I'm not too proud to admit that I have made a mistake. When I first read the sentence that I quoted above - I mistakenly read it as "Fibonacci claimed that consistent patterns could be found in the stock market from what appeared to be random prices". And I immediately said to myself that for someone so outspoken and ready to critisize the matter at hand -- the guy could know his history...

At any rate, I won't say anything about what he wrote except that his assumptions are not in accord with my own experiences...

PEACE and good-specul8tion...

#10     Nov 12, 2003
ET IS FREE BECAUSE OF THE FINANCIAL SUPPORT FROM THESE COMPANIES: