ES Journal - 2023/2024

Discussion in 'Journals' started by Buy1Sell2, Dec 6, 2022.

  1. schizo

    schizo

    I need to kvetch. I'm such a jackass. So so stupid! :banghead:

    Does anyone know exactly why ES topped out at 4109 today? At the time, I didn't understand. Well, now I know.

    I was so wrapped up with THE trendline, I didn't realize there would be another trendline. Once we passed above THE trendline, I thought we were done with 4000.

    Here is the chart I was monitoring at the time.

    upload_2023-1-27_19-43-48.png

    And here's the trendline that passed undetected well below the radar.

    upload_2023-1-27_19-43-12.png

    Moral of this post: Don't get so caught up in your own narrow views.
     
    #1491     Jan 27, 2023
    formikatrading likes this.
  2. jetbird

    jetbird

    LT trendlines for ES will vary depending on the data and time period used. I wish TradingView had backadjusted futures data. The S&P 500 cash index already backtested the LT trendline and is moving higher.
     
    #1492     Jan 27, 2023
    Laissez Faire likes this.
  3. schizo

    schizo

    They do.

    upload_2023-1-27_20-42-39.png
     
    #1493     Jan 27, 2023
    Laissez Faire and jetbird like this.
  4. jetbird

    jetbird

    Wow, finally! Thanks
     
    #1494     Jan 27, 2023
  5. Didn't I say the HOD would most likely come in the last hour and that 4100 would be a point to start considering an exit? :)

    I'm not sure trend lines is a factor, though.
     
    #1495     Jan 28, 2023
  6. Trend lines

    Funny how everyone's chart are looking different.

    I think this must come from different ways to draw them AND also using different trading hours. I use the US Equities RTH session strictly which should be the same as the cash index. I don't think TradingView offers that one, but will let it go all the way to 16:15. And that's fine. Some like to use that. I don't.

    For me, I resolved most issues when I stopped using or expecting trend lines to be a precision tool. I consider it more of a rough tool and support parameter which could give an indication of where we're going and where we might start looking for a turn.

    If you consider a what a trend line or channel is - it's basically a measured move and an indication of where and how the market is moving. Sometimes these are surprisngly accurate. Other times they're more in the ballpark.

    I tried to work out some rules for how to use trend lines, but you very often get edge cases which will challenge those rules, i.e., some times it seems to make sense to include a spike high/low. Other times not. So, to me, there's some artistry involved here.

    When a trend line is perfectly respected to the tick I consider that more random than anything else, but trend line believers will discard every other time where the trend line was overshot/undershot.

    The major trend line I have drawn on my daily chart certainly had the market closing above it on Friday. I don't pay any special significance to that, though. We're headed into some major possible resistance in this area still, so I'm very cautious to the long side here.

    Next week there's also the FOMC on Wednesday which can really f''k with everyone's trend lines. LOL. :)

    upload_2023-1-28_13-44-0.png
     
    #1496     Jan 28, 2023
    Builder17 likes this.
  7. Similar view on SPX Daily. Which also highlights why I think we're in a potential sell zone. Personally, I think it'd be nuts to start shorting on that basis alone. So, I'm not. But I'm paying attention for sure.

    upload_2023-1-28_13-48-48.png

    Monthly supply/demand on SPX below.

    Currently bounded by supply at ~ 4150 and demand at ~ 3600.

    upload_2023-1-28_13-50-37.png
     
    #1497     Jan 28, 2023
  8. Had few minutes to do some bigger picture analysis. As of now, still project we will be up for Q1, but February could be a little more challenging than January - not typically a really strong month from a seasonality perspective. I'm seeing a pattern on RTY weekly which typically suggests a down move (for this upcoming week) so keeping that in mind, along with how I read VIX. Expect bitcoin and long-term bonds to be up for Q1 as well so I don't see the market falling off a cliff. Just my 2cents

    Related to this, the equal-weight S&P 500 has been leading this rally until recently (see the ratio line).

    upload_2023-1-28_11-8-35.png
     
    #1498     Jan 28, 2023
    Laissez Faire likes this.
  9. Another perspective.

    We're definitely coming into a zone that have had some significance in the most recent past.

    upload_2023-1-28_17-43-39.png
     
    #1499     Jan 28, 2023
    formikatrading likes this.
  10. schizo

    schizo

    Well, yes, that's kinda no brainer. But here's what I think most people don't understand about trendlines. While you need to connect two dots to draw a line, you need THREE TOUCHES (or more) for it to be valid. A two touch trendline is not very reliable. Otherwise, it becomes too subjective and willy nilly.

    upload_2023-1-28_11-55-26.png

    upload_2023-1-28_12-1-27.png
     
    #1500     Jan 28, 2023