LOL I can assure you that making a blind call on the market direction and posting actual trades are not the same thing (even though nobody pays attention my trades anyway). As to your comment about "fudging", well... at least, I try to post my trades as realistically as possible to the actual time of the trade, which is usually under a minute. There's really no way for me to fudge my trade because you can clearly see whether I'm making or losing money. Isn't that alone better than those who report their trades HOURS later and claim that they were profitable?
Posting your journal in someone else's journal seems unwieldy. Start your own, it's fun! And you still have not mentioned where your stop and targets are for the 57.50 short.
Perhaps you're not aware that I've been intermittently posting my trades in the "ES Journal" (this and the previous ones) going all the way back to 2004.