Do you have a EDGE over the market?

Discussion in 'Technical Analysis' started by benysl, Jul 20, 2005.

  1. Depends on the time of day and the volume. In the morning, with high volume, MMs let the crowd take the market where they will, and content themselves with the spread and making the crowd periodically slightly wrong by shaking them out of their good positions with retraces. During mid-day and in low volume, they lead the crowd around by the nose by repeatedly making their majority positions wrong. It is easy to show that all day long the crowd is wrong by at least the spread, and often by as much as a tick more. Nice work if you can get it. The only way to win is to judo their style. Regards. Al.
     
    #11     Jul 20, 2005
  2. ig0r

    ig0r

    ROFL are you out of your mind? you obviously don't trade for a living. you have no idea what you're talking about and are completely off base as to what, if any, power a market maker has. I think I'm done with this thread this is a joke
     
    #12     Jul 20, 2005
  3. Holmes

    Holmes

    Rubbish. There are more ways than one to skin a cat.

    Sherlock

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    Tao te Ching, tetragram 56:

    Those who know do not speak
    Those who speak do not know
    Block the passages
    Close the door
    Blunt the sharpness
    Untie the tangles
    Harmonize with the brightness
    Identify with the way of the world
     
    #13     Jul 20, 2005
  4. I am really hopeful that more and more of those people get a trading account as soon as possible and add some liquidity.

    I stole that one.
     
    #14     Jul 20, 2005
  5. NKNY

    NKNY



    Determine the trend of the market on a long term basis and enter batch positions on a short term basis. Short term for me is 2 to 6 weeks. I use batch trades because 1... Reduces risk, you gotta be nuts to put all your money in one or two stocks. 2... They way I pick stocks I usually get one or two or three in the group that really take off (or drop like a rockwhen short). 3...You never really know which stock is going to move.

    If you only enter one or two stocks, the whole market could be advancing and your stocks can still go down. This is a numbers game not a stock prediction game.





    Here is some real stats from 5/2004 to present...

    Compounded Rate of Return 38.52%

    108 winners 102 losers total 210 trades for 51%

    What keeps me in the green is my average winners to losers...
    Ave winners Avg losers
    Long Trades $1,323.93 ($836.28)
    Short Trades $800.89 ($465.30)
    All Trades $1,057.28 ($616.72)



    But In my opinion your barking up the wrong tree...... I actually just broke above the 50 % mark with my last trades over the last two months... I'm was in the 47 to 49 % from 2004. But then again 2004 was a crappy year for trendfollowing. But in reality, it wouldn't hurt to have both on your side... % trades profitable and average winners to losers....

    I did a back test from 2000 and was at 57 % winners but again the real key is in the average winners to losers. The backtested
    Compounded Rate of Return was 140 % :). Of course this is assuming we could have shorted all the stocks that the system picked to short....In any event the system thrives on a trending market..up or down...

    From 1997 my backtested results were 73 % winners...but everything was going up from 1997 to 2000. Compounded Rate of Return was 123 %

    So to answer your question...define your trend...then apply it consistently ....trade portfolios of at least 15 ...not a few stocks ....

    when you need to buy stocks buy good ones that are meeting and beating estimates and when your shorting, short junk.

    Good luck ...

    Nick
     
    #15     Jul 20, 2005
  6. benysl

    benysl

    it is getting off topic, ok perhaps a simpler version first
    Toss a coin and it will land either head or tail 50% of the time assuming both side is equal.

    How do we let it turn head up > 50%??

    10 head in a row will not make the next toss turn tail up 51%.

    Agree on this??
     
    #16     Jul 20, 2005
  7. benysl

    benysl


    good post Nick, thanks
     
    #17     Jul 20, 2005
  8. Holmes

    Holmes

    Rubbish too.

    When a tiger gets hungry he goes looking for some yum-yum food. When he sees a nice herd of yum-yum he will select his prey. And then chase that prey back and forth until it is yum-yum time. If he is chasing and then decides to chase another prey, and then another prey no yum-yum time is to be had. (which is what cubs do).

    Moral: Focus on one thing, and one thing only. Learn all the ins and outs of that. Then wait for the right opportunity.

    Sherlock
     
    #18     Jul 20, 2005
  9. benysl

    benysl

    Someone posted this

    *****************************
    How to win with 30% accuracy:

    Expectation = (Win% x WinSize) - (Lose% - LoseSize)

    E = (30% x $1000) - (70% x $300)
    E = (0.3 x $1000) - (0.7 x $300)
    E = $90
    *****************************

    From Maths view the above is not VALID

    You enter a trade what is the chances of it hitting $1000 profit and what is the chances of it hitting $300 stop loss
    % of it hitting $1000 profit = 23.077%
    % of it hitting $300 loss = 76.923%

    To calculate a 30% vs 70%
    30% to win $910
    70% to loss $390
    or
    30% to lose $910
    70% to win $390

    Thus the above scernario after a 100 trades net position is 0 (excluding commission for simplicity)

    thus back to my topic, from a mathetician points of view how do you increase the EDGE?
     
    #19     Jul 20, 2005
  10. RAY

    RAY

    Since when does flipping a coin and trading have anything to do with one-another?

    on a side note: spin a penny on a table and see if it is 50/50...
     
    #20     Jul 20, 2005