Do Trendlines work?

Discussion in 'Technical Analysis' started by duard, Apr 3, 2005.

  1. chart
     
    #941     Jul 5, 2005
  2. YM 5m update with targets shown
     
    #942     Jul 5, 2005
  3. update to 5m YM
     
    #943     Jul 5, 2005
  4. John

    If this is for me. I believe trendlines exist. If they
    are seen only later (after the fact) it makes no
    difference. And yes, all the basic support and
    resistance stuff, as you have mentioned.

    Stephen Szpak



    Pray do explain yourself. I believe a profound thought lurks within that post. Unlike your previous one, which failed to mention the possibility of buying or seeling pressure in a horizontal move
     
    #944     Jul 6, 2005
  5. Jack

    I have read and reread these passages many times and I still dont get it:

    (Seriously, that a parallel line works is a deep and pervasive statement about the intimate connection of price and volume on the chosen trading fractal.

    The line parallel to the trend line is there and works and is a statement for time immemorial. Why? The consciousness of the marketplace caused by the complex of people in it is a stable and huge enterprise. Millionaire barbers epitimize how informal information seeps through the system. This glue leads to conclusions.)

    I have no doubt channels work often enough to make them valuable but I am still puzzling over why they work. The first paragraph above seems to hint at a mathematical relationship and the second a psychological reason. Any chance you could go into it some more? I dont need to understand this to use them but it bugs me.

    What a beautiful channel this morning.
     
    #945     Jul 8, 2005
  6. Hey:

    My job is to take 10 points out of the market. After that I could care less. I entered long on the third bar with a 1 point stop loss

    Posted the chart on another thread this morning, but the moderator apparently thought it should be "purged" :D

    Ozzy, if you are looking for some commentary, send me a PM and I'll provide some direction.

    See ya
    Steve

    Edit:

    By the way, if you "see" trendlines only after the fact, that means you aren't making money. Those of us who actually trade, "visualize" potential trend lines all the time. Its called using your imagination. All you need to make a potential trendline tangible is two points. How hard do you want to make this? To go from point A to point B, the shortest route is a straight line (except on a sphere). Keep working on it, and you will eventually get there.
     
    #946     Jul 8, 2005
  7. Please disregard this, 'cause it's not what's being referred to. And now... I'll just be quiet. :)
     
    #947     Jul 8, 2005
  8. steve46

    I couldn't tell from the graph what I was looking at.
    Was it the E-mini S&P 500?

    So you shoot for 10 points a day ( up or down ) and
    then exit for the day? Or do you hope for 10 points but
    take as much as you can get before the trendline breaks?

    Do you actually get 10 points on a majority of days?


    My job is to take 10 points out of the market. After that I could care less. I entered long on the third bar with a 1 point stop loss

    Thanks for any input here,

    Regards,

    Stephen Szpak
     
    #948     Jul 9, 2005
  9. Hello:

    In response to your questions

    1. Yes
    2. Yes
    3. Yes

    Steve
     
    #949     Jul 9, 2005
  10. Steve

    Actually I asked 4 questions, but I'm sure
    you saw that. I appreciate the input.

    Do you
    have the time/desire to answer basic questions
    about trading the E-mini S&P 500 futures? I don't
    want to be bothersome.

    Regards,

    Stephen Szpak
     
    #950     Jul 9, 2005