Do my numbers make sense?

Discussion in 'Automated Trading' started by Adim, Nov 17, 2021.

  1. Adim

    Adim

    This is a Grasshoper test, yes? Did you see the part where I showed how the program did during the recent correction?

    On another note... is it a test of a good trading program that the manager of the program is not allowed to read newspapers to learn about a rapidly spreading epidemic in China which may not yet be reflected in the SP500?

    I have come here to learn something, not to be dumped upon, but thank you for testing my manhood
     
    #11     Nov 17, 2021
  2. lindq

    lindq

    You report that your average holding time is 13 days and you average 33 open positions, and trade long only.

    Hopefully you have serious risk controls in place. You'll need them.
     
    #12     Nov 17, 2021
  3. Adim

    Adim

    > You report that your average holding time is 13 days and you average 33 open positions, and trade long only.

    i am not very leveraged. in fact, most days i am not even 100% invested
     
    #13     Nov 17, 2021
  4. Adim

    Adim

    I dont know guys... I was NOT looking for sniping. I already know from my wife that i am mentally retarded, I hardly need you to help me with that insight.

    Does anyone have anything useful to say?
     
    #14     Nov 17, 2021
  5. deaddog

    deaddog

    What are your sept stats?
    Winners, losers, etc. ?
    What was your biggest loser, winner, win %, R to R?

    Didn't your backtest have any losing months?
     
    #15     Nov 17, 2021
  6. hilmy83

    hilmy83

    Lolol almost spit my coffee
     
    #16     Nov 17, 2021
    beginner66 and SunTrader like this.
  7. traider

    traider

    It feels like you are not calculating sharpe correctly , you should double check. You outperformed SPY but the magnitude seems to be more like 2x or 3x and not what your sharpe says. HFT turnover gets you to sharpe 10+ but it is rare for other type of strategies.
    How did you manage to see the decline coming for Covid or GFC? Do you have any false positives for detecting market crashes because false positives are also costly.
     
    #17     Nov 17, 2021
  8. Adim

    Adim

    traider
    it is entirely possible that i am not calculating Sharpe correctly. would you like to help me with that? is there some way we can text directly?
    also, i just learned there was something called Sortino. Not from qlaid (or whatever his handle sez), 'koz of course his job is to haze newbies.
    like i said, I have been a manual trader all my life, I am just learning this stuff.
    Avoiding the Covid crash was not hard. All you had to do is read the press. It helped that I read Chinese and Japanese, and had lived in Asia, and had been in Malaysia during the SARS epidemic. beyond that it was just a matter of reading the press and drawing on your own experience. I was actually short oil into negative prices, as a result. i gather from the few replies here that quant trading means one must be too proud to know anything beyond the numbers in front of him. (is this weird?). "we dont read the press, we dont interpret the news"? is that, like, virtuous, or something?
    GFC was perhaps less obvious, but i was not computer trading at the time, all manual, and through an European bank with extremely high fees (like $100 per trade minimum, i am not making this up, this is how the rest of us -- the other half -- live). and, as a result, sometime in 2005 i went all cash in AUD at .78c because I could see nothing else that was worth owning. at that time AUD paid 7.5% per year. with market valuations at what they were, it just seemed smart to own an undervalued currency (on burgernomics basis) paying 7.5%. i started dipping my toe in by buying MBIA CHF 18 month debt in december 2007 at 70c. (it eventually went down to .65c in January 2009).
     
    #18     Nov 17, 2021
  9. SunTrader

    SunTrader

    You can talk manhood, I'll stick with trading. Going loooong AND short, no pun intended. LOL
     
    #19     Nov 17, 2021
  10. Adim

    Adim

    deaddog

    i cant say if my backtest had any negative months because i did not run it as a backtest of a portfolio (maybe i should, Im just a newbie, should i? i just assumed that if you get every trade right, then portfolio will follow?). so... i ran it as a backtest of so many trades, without agglomeration. the backtest showed various rates for winners/losers depending on sector. so, for example, SP500 individual stocks showed 68/32. but if you tested for sector ETFS (in the XL..., family), then it was more like 72/28.

    your other questions, i can only answer regarding my actual trading results (since April 2, 7.5 months): my win ratio was 93% (?! seems really weird). my biggest winner was 12.78% (a real outlier, the next one was 10.19%, the next one after that 8.06%, then 6.44%, then everything lese 4-handle or less) my biggest loser was -1.1%. what is R to R?
     
    Last edited: Nov 17, 2021
    #20     Nov 17, 2021