Do full-time forex traders exist or is it just make believe?

Where is the proof that you can trade profitably? I don't think I've seen that but I could be wrong

 

Well said surf. Let's show 'em your PD statements first and then they will all run for cover.

 

I don't trade FX. Everyone has or has had profits. This thread is about professional at home retail FX traders Not me or bank traders, prop traders or anything else.

Heck, even Tim Sykes has the lifestyle befitting success. Most FX traders struggle and there are no retail professionsals making a decent living strictly from retail Fx.

 

Changing the subject back onto me isn't going to work.i make no claims. That isn't evidence of what is requested. Let me guess, this alias is going to regurgitate more book wisdom and rhetoric to obfuscate the question. It's all they have and some ( particularly stealth vendors) have become skilled at it. Unfortunately, for them, it doesn't work.

 

Trading FX is no different from any other market from TA perspective. FX is harder not structurally, but due to less predictable volatility.

 

Oops, did I tread on a tender toe?

Now about this stealth vending, it's pretty stealthy isn't it? But you're not changing the subject are you? Now are you the same surf that made endless claims about your PD's predicting the market, or was that another surf? And is this the same surf that claims PD leave TA in it's wake - or are you a different surf that makes no claims? Sorry, I get confused between the surf's on ET

Or if I talk to you in the same terms that you use, you'll do your ritual dance about hate vibes and not understanding why you're picked on - isn't that so, or is that s different surf??

And are you the same surf that got banned from ET for stealth marketing? Or was that a different surf?

 

It's the same thing over and over again from you. I make no claims. You do.
Clearly the PD's didn't work as expected. So what? I don't lie about them.
There is only one surf -- and he hasn't seen any evidence of anyone making a living trading retail FX. Just the same thing over and over again. It's a comedy show.

Folks, as you can see these FX retail pros are FOS about their claims. There is no evidence. Don't get sucked in by the rhetoric.

 

Surf, what about index futures? Do you believe trading for a living there is possible?

 

Yes. I know at home professional index future traders. But they don't trade with charts or as you might expect not to mention, they all either have prop backing OR independent wealth from other sources. I know no one who started with 5k or so and is no trading solely for a living without prop backing. surf

 

What did I claim sir? What is the rhetoric? Sucked into what? Where is the vending I am doing? And what exactly do we owe you?