Here is a logo I made in GIMP. The text and color of the forum would also have to be changed to match any new logo.
Baron is on the right track to modernize the look of EliteTrader, bring it out of the 1990's and into the present time. ALL major sites have updated their look, Yahoo, Google, Youtube, Facebook, Ebay, Hotmail. I think Yahoo Finance and Google Finance should be the template for EliteTrader.
And the 2 that mostly resemble ET, Reddit and Craigslist DIDN'T... (none of you mentioned is a message board) But what about alternating it? Over the weekend keep the blue, during the week green it is. So when you wake up with a hangover and you see the blue one, you know you can go back to sleep...