Cornix's Forex Trading Journal

Discussion in 'Journals' started by cornix, Jan 5, 2011.

  1. 5 sec is WAY too quick. 10 second is too especially for any form of fading. 30 second is decent and most traders use the 1 min but even that's a bit quick. If you're just starting out use a 5 min chart and learn to take proper signals. Then drop it down. I wouldn't try running until you learn how to walk :).....personal experience.

    The only place I could get by with a 10 sec chart and gain an edge was trading breakouts ironically (E/U moves quick). Trying to get early signals on tops and bottoms chopped me to death and I had to go back to 1 min (sometimes 30 sec).
     
    #181     Jan 23, 2011
  2. targus

    targus

    Hello Athlonmank8,

    I am in full agreement with you, 5sec is way to small.

    But I do not use this timeframe to do my charting, I merely use this particular platform, which so happens to have a 5second period, because of the execution speeds, good spreads and size of broker. However, it is also useful for the study of momentum on that other popular term 'price action'.

    I use a different platform for charting and using the donchian channels (old fashioned, but it seems to work) to quickly show me support and resistance within all the timeframes, from 5min,1 hour,4 hour, daily, weekly and monthly. When I enter a price it is based on the weekly/daily and 4hr to access the overall main trend, then I will enter a trade on either the 5minute timeframe or the 4hour timeframe and only going long if the main trend on the daily is long.
     
    #182     Jan 23, 2011
  3. What bothers me, unless I am mistaken, is that you may be focused on too many 'ingredients' when it seems that you intended to simply look for 'scalps'...

    Simplify ...

    NiN
     
    #183     Jan 23, 2011
  4. cornix

    cornix

    Yeah, making strategy too complicated more often hurts than helps. Simple works.
     
    #184     Jan 24, 2011
  5. cornix

    cornix

    Today I am starting scalping experiment, no idea how long will it last, all depends on real time testing results:

    will only trade for ~3-3.5 hours a day (from approximately 7:00 GMT to 10:00 GMT) to see if making decent profits possible by having enough free time too... :p
     
    #185     Jan 24, 2011
  6. targus

    targus

    Hi Guys
    Good trading. I'm hoping she goes up at least some point today, according to my charts. She is hugging the 30ma on the 15m t/f at the moment, lots of indecision.
     
    #186     Jan 24, 2011
  7. cornix

    cornix

    S @ 1.3601. Against the 00 #, but worth the try.
     
    #187     Jan 24, 2011
  8. cornix

    cornix

    Took profit of my infamous 9 pips. :)
     
    #188     Jan 24, 2011
  9. Roark

    Roark

    WTF just happened? Would you say that this is a good reason to always have a stop in place?
     
    #189     Jan 24, 2011
  10. cornix

    cornix

    Oh yeah... But this time I got lucky to be holding the position in direction of this dump... And it went less than in a tick from my stop-loss, but didn't touch it.
     
    #190     Jan 24, 2011