College Playoffs for 2019 Season

Discussion in 'Sports' started by Hari Seldon, Oct 11, 2019.

  1. Wallet

    Wallet

    Merry Christmas :D
     
    #41     Dec 29, 2019
    vanzandt likes this.
  2. speedo

    speedo

    :D:thumbsup:
     
    #42     Dec 29, 2019
  3. Wallet

    Wallet

    Orange or Yellow Tiger?
     
    #43     Jan 13, 2020
  4. speedo

    speedo

    The real Tigers of Baton Rouge
     
    #44     Jan 13, 2020
  5. Wallet

    Wallet

    Friend of mine, huge LSU fan, pulled a hamstring I think cheering them on, lol.

    Heck of a team this year. :thumbsup:
     
    #45     Jan 14, 2020
    speedo likes this.
  6. vanzandt

    vanzandt

    Only Alabama could get a #1 ranking without playing a single friggin' game until 9/26.

    LSU #9 Speedo. :D

    The good news is, this is the first time in like 110 years UM and OSU aren't in the top 50.
    Fear not however all you Wolverine/Suckeye fans... I have a feeling money will talk in the end.
    And they'll still lose in January.
     
    #46     Sep 14, 2020
  7. speedo

    speedo

    #6 AP, #5 Coaches but the rankings this time of year and about a buck will get you a cup of Joe down at the truck stop.
     
    #47     Sep 14, 2020
  8. vanzandt

    vanzandt

    Well, the Big 10 is back in.

    College Football Playoff selection committee has new predicament with Big Ten joining fray
    8:00 AM ET

    If I were a member of the College Football Playoff selection committee this season, I would apply for a sabbatical. Or to the Peace Corps. Or to go just about anywhere else besides those selection committee Zoom calls that will begin Nov. 17.

    College Football Playoff executive director Bill Hancock's crew might have to try to discern the difference between, say, a 9-0 Big Ten team and an 11-1 ACC team.

    Then explain it.

    Then duck.

    In a sport that gave us split national champions, the BCS formula, and debates that never die, we are on the cusp of a season that could deliver spectacular chaos. Think about it: The Big Ten teams will play eight-game regular seasons, the SEC and Big 12 will play 10-game regular seasons, and the ACC plans to go one game beyond that. Throw in a championship game for the two best teams in each conference.

    [​IMG]
    Big Ten football is back: What you need to know
    Now, tell me how to fairly size up one team that has played a schedule one-third longer than another. Do you penalize the team that played fewer games? Do you reward the team that played more but has a worse record? Do you set the schedule differences aside and measure performance only? Do you bang yourself in the head with a mallet because it feels better than deciding whether an undefeated Wisconsin is better than a once-beaten Georgia?

    I mean, as potential autumn nightmares go, it's not a disputed presidential election, but it'll do.

    What about the teams forced to take a COVID-19 break for a game or two? Do you penalize Clemson if Syracuse no-shows? And what do we do with playoff contenders or their opponents whose rosters are shrunken by the virus?

    Najee Harris and Alabama will open their season Sept. 26 against a Missouri team that will be down 12 players because of COVID-19. Reinhold Matay/USA TODAY Sports
    Alabama opens next week against a Missouri team that will be short 12 players. The selection committee trumpets its protocol for taking key injuries into account when assessing the results of a game. Tigers coach Eli Drinkwitz didn't say Wednesday where the 12 Tigers land on the depth chart. But it seems reasonable that (A) the Crimson Tide won't get a lot of style points for winning, and (B) the Crimson Tide won't be the only team that faces a diminished opponent.

    As with everything else in intercollegiate athletics this calendar year, we are in uncharted territory. But it seems as if the selection committee's normally difficult task just upped its game, as if the members signed up for conversational Russian and were told to translate "War and Peace."

    I point this out as someone who clamored for a selection committee long before we ever got one. NCAA tournament fields long have been filled by asking knowledgeable administrators to fill out the brackets. College football remained an outlier for decades. Just about every other college sport utilized a selection committee. But the administrators didn't want to do that for football. They liked bowl games. They liked going to warm places for New Year's Day. They liked polls.

    Even when they approved a playoff beginning in 1998, the administrators chose not to appoint a selection committee. They didn't want the responsibility of selecting the teams. So they came up with an idea: Let's create a formula that no one will understand! That's one reason the BCS had so much trouble establishing credibility. (See the Florida State-Miami-Washington-Oregon State debate of 2000, the USC-LSU debate of 2003, the USC-Oklahoma-Auburn-Utah debate of 2004, etc.)

    The CFP selection committee got it right in its first year, picking Ohio State and running back Ezekiel Elliott as the No. 4 team in, then seeing the Buckeyes win the national championship. Tom Pennington/Getty Images
    We didn't get a selection committee until 2014, when the BCS was put to bed and we got a four-team playoff. And you know what? The committee nailed its landing that first year, picking Ohio State for the No. 4 seed over TCU or Baylor. We will never know whether the Horned Frogs or Bears should have been given a shot at the national championship, but we learned pretty quickly that the Buckeyes were good enough.

    Hancock has tried to keep things simple in this unsimple season. He has said the committee will continue to execute its charge -- to pick the four best teams in college football. That gray area will benefit the committee. It's hard to argue against it.

    If this were Major League Baseball, and we identified the four best teams simply by winning percentage, someone would be at a disadvantage. St. Louis postponed 18 games early in their 60-game season because of a pandemic pause. The Cardinals are attempting to play 32 games in September, which isn't fair to them. They also have seven doubleheaders on their schedule, 14 seven-inning games, which isn't fair to the rest of the National League.

    The Big Ten didn't announce it will hold any jamborees to make up for lost games. But keeping 14 teams sufficiently healthy to play eight games in eight weeks is daunting enough. Last season, by the way, no Big Ten team played more than seven weeks in a row.

    The selection committee might not make the right decision. It's hard to imagine how it will, measuring apples against oranges. But the selection committee is the system we have.

    "Democracy is the worst form of Government except for all those other forms that have been tried," Winston Churchill said on Nov. 11, 1947, a day on which Notre Dame and Michigan were ranked 1-2 for the first time. They traded positions twice before the end of the year. The writers voted for the Irish. Others awarded No. 1 to the Wolverines. And 73 years later, you can still goad their fans into an argument over it.
     
    #48     Sep 17, 2020
  9. speedo

    speedo

    They'll put OSU back again and again OSU will lose.
     
    #49     Sep 17, 2020
    vanzandt likes this.
  10. UGA isn't the team I thought they would be so not sure how much it meant for USCe to beat them at both lines of scrimmage. NC almost beat Clemson. Dabo is notorious for blowing games.
     
    #50     Sep 17, 2020