My disagreement with the premise of time and price prediction or any other observation is not necessarily a put down. It is first and foremost an expression of a difference of opinion. Is there something wrong with that? I don't post trades. On the few occasions during the day that I may be in a trade for brief moments at a time, I have no time to post because I am reacting rather than predicting. Such posting would be after the fact and of no value to anyone. In any event, I certainly don't make anywhere near the numbers that schizo has presented in the P&L thread, so you wouldn't be impressed anyway.
I certainly hope you are not referring to me. I know full well that money can be made trading intraday, and I certainly don't doubt that money can be made swing trading interday. And I am not suggesting that you are not making money. I am simply expressing my opinion that your time/price predictions are unintended humor. I think that any money you make is more in spite of such predictions rather than because of them. But since that is not the prevailing view in this thread and dissenting opinions are frowned upon, I shall refrain from posting in your thread in the future.