No edge ... by itself. Well what does, besides being Fed Chair or a casino operator not named Trumpie.
You starting to sound like a snake oil salesman (not saying that you are) when comfronted with evidence the next step is to obfuscate and always without evidence. Again, no edge.
I misworded my post, sorry for that, I meant that those that claim edge cannot provide evidence. Did the work years ago, indicators are useless.
I understand you found .... that you had no edge using indicators. Must be a PHD available from Ivy League University or a book deal maybe called A Random Indicator Walk Down Wall Street or something. Anyway I gave my 2 cents, you gave yours. Let the OP decide.
That being said, divergences are extremely useful in entry and exit discovery. What I have found is that when someone says that they don't work, they likely just haven't had success with identifying the proper ones.