Tough call between Rodgers, Rivers, Roethlisberger and Schaub. Personally, I am impressed by Rodgers and have always like Rivers, so I would rank them as 4 and 5. I think going on last year though, you have to say Favre was 4. McNabb threw for nearly 500 yards last week. Maybe he gets reborn as a Redskin (or maybe as a Viking next year). And the one guy I would tune in a game just to watch. No question, Mike Vick. Can't believe I feel that way but the guy has been just electric.