Beginners without any forex trading experience should stick to demo accounts or brokers like Avatrade and FP Markets that provide educational materials to learn about forex.
the beginners should choose the broker which is more appropriate to the concept of trading that will be used .
Try FP markets. It is an ASIC-regulated broker that offers some of the lowest spreads and commissions. I trade with them from Austria and did not face any major issues like severe freezing or withdrawals.
I suggest beginners trade with properly regulated brokers that also provide educational materials to develop knowledge and strategies. You can try Avatrade or FP Markets, I personally would suggest FP Markets because of its lower commission cost, which is $3 per lot. They also offer a variety of educational materials, such as e-books, and their customer service is quick to respond to any questions.
From the list and reviews mentioned, I think you should add Etoro and FP Markets, because these two brokers provide some of the best trading conditions with good customer service. I previously traded with ICM and had a bad experience with their customer service, so I'm not sure on what basis they came in as the best on the list, whereas FP Markets has better spreads and even a lower minimum opening balance of $100 AUD.
You are right. For example, I like to trade intraday and scalp, making trades for a small number of points. Therefore, tight spreads and instant execution are important to me first of all. Therefore, I chose a regulated broker fxopen for this type of trading, which has a spread of only 0.1 -0.2 for the EURUSD pair that I often trade.
I like to trade with brokers that don’t pay gormless loons like you to promote their bucket shop all over the internet
You can compare a broker's financials if you go here; https://www.cftc.gov/sites/default/files/2023-08/01 - FCM Webpage Update - June 2023.pdf