Baruch's Forex System Journal

Discussion in 'Journals' started by Baruch, Mar 11, 2004.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. No, those types of rumors tend to make there way around the floor the morning of. Also it's a holiday here in the US; everyone is out of town or having a barbecue.
     
    #1771     May 31, 2004
  2. euro and cable are on weak side of the last 24 hours now
     
    #1772     May 31, 2004
  3. OK - nice to know. But please keep us informed.
     
    #1773     May 31, 2004
  4. "Whatever men attempt, they seem driven to try to overdo. When hopes are soaring I always repeat to myself, "Two and two still make four and no one has ever invented a way of getting something for nothing". When the outlook is steeped in pessimism I remind myself, "Two and two still make four and you can't keep mankind down for long".
     
    #1774     May 31, 2004
  5. Backtesting is OK, but realtime trading is better. Let's trade our two systems and let's see which one is the best.

    They are both good, because:

    1. They catch all the major moves.
    2. They limit losses.

    They both have problems, because:

    1. There are no sure rules for exit (trailing stops are OK, but not perfect).
    2. They will give many losses in a choppy market/trading range.
     
    #1775     May 31, 2004
  6. Buk

    Buk

    test
     
    #1776     Jun 1, 2004
  7. Buk

    Buk

    Agree Baruch, both strats will indeed prove difficult in ranging mkts, and the stop loss (trade management) debate is a continuous bone of contention regards trend following strats. But as far as “which strat is best”….hmmm, although they have similar objectives, the entry/management & structure of them are very different imo.

    Yours works perfectly, returning good, consistant profits from the methods you adopt, and mine evolves in to a trend strat from an intraday perspective, so really, they’re very different in their make up. I don’t think either strat is better or worse even in similar trading environments. There will be periods when yours produces very consistant returns and vice versa…..I initiate entries via a shorter time frame & scale lots out at pre – defined stages, attempting to catch a move by leaving part of my position live in the market with a b/e stop. Where as you trade off the 30 min frame with defined entry/exit rules….There are many individual quirks & personal observations which each trader uses to base their decisions when managing a trade, some of them intuitive, so it’s very difficult & virtually impossible to compare like for like.

    Take this morning for instance, my intraday entry confirmed 3 long trades on the cable, I scaled out at part stakes, leaving remaining lots at b/e stop, only to be tipped out on the p/b from the round number failure on my remaining stake(s).

    The objective of my strat is to capture small intraday moves, whilst maintaining a ‘live’ stake at b/e until sufficient movement allows to trail the stop on a potential trend move away from entry……very different to your entry/trade management structure…..I guess as long as both strats produce profit, then they fulfill their purpose.

    ps: have had difficulty posting this morning?!....each time I attempted to post, the page simply went blank & refused to upload the post??
     
    #1777     Jun 1, 2004
  8. Both systems made good buy signals this morning.
     
    #1778     Jun 1, 2004
  9. Buk,

    Yes, ET was down earlier today.

    I agree with you: ..."as long as both strats produce profit, then they fullfill their purpose".

    Yes, maybe it's better calling them strats rather than systems...
     
    #1779     Jun 1, 2004
  10. #1780     Jun 1, 2004
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.