Baron - Is Nazism a fun joke for you and ET?

Discussion in 'Politics' started by Bruto Blukowski, Apr 2, 2007.

  1. Mvic

    Mvic

    The best cure for ignorance and intolerance is an open and frank discussion. Fanatics of all stripes need to be given enough rope to hang themselves as they always do with their radical dogma that any rational person would dismiss if they heard it in its entirely. Banning and censoring just gives credibility to their whine of persecution. It sends them to the dark corners where they can get away with half truths that go unrebutted. It allows them to draw in the naive and unsophisticated. Shine a bright light on them I say and let them expose themselves for what they are. Their ignorant and frankly ridiculous points of view are enough completely self defeating, so I say let them speak as much as they want exposing the lies for what they are at every step.

    Having said that why on earth would they post on a site about trading? Keeping them confined to the P&R sections seems like a good compromise.
     
    #21     Apr 3, 2007
  2. Prove it...:p
     
    #22     Apr 3, 2007

  3. Don't really want to bother myself. The Holohoax isn't something I worry about too much.

    As a point of interest, I took the time to read this Bruto fellows posts. His posts on Arabs and Palestinians are more bigoted and fascist in nature than any of Hitlers speeches.
     
    #23     Apr 3, 2007
  4. They are the ones making the assertion and it is THEY that should prove it.
    How many Russians/Ukrainians died in Camps during the war?

    I'll give you a clue....A lot more than 6 million
     
    #24     Apr 4, 2007
  5. man

    man

    why all this hypocrite whining about limit of freedom
    here? this is not a porn site, so when you want to see
    porn go and get it somewhere else. if you want nazi
    stuff, same thing. no big deal.

    and for those all coming up with this zionist thing, the
    reason why the holocaust is so prominent is not just
    the jews but because it happened in one of the most
    civilised western countries. and right now the region
    where the remains of that crisis live is at center
    of constant world wide attention. and it has been like
    that for decades. the assumption that a people invents
    something like the holocaust is so far fetched it is not
    worth debating ... or, well at some places where real
    honorable men do their thing.
     
    #25     Apr 4, 2007
  6. man

    man

    started funny, then it had no punch line. 2 out of 10.
     
    #26     Apr 4, 2007
  7. man

    man

    it looks like it was proven all over again. in court. in documentaries,
    in numerous autobiographies of victims, in hundreds of studies
    and papers world wide. the point here is that if someone gets
    into it by saying everybody is lying, every court, every victim,
    every relative of a victim, every confessing nazi, every academic
    who studied it, how can you "prove" it to them? if you "know" that
    the world is running a conspiracy against you, no one can "prove"
    the opposite, since each argument is seen as part of the conspiracy.

    and see how it all adds up. in Publisher's eyes it was the jews
    who stabbed the german ("undefeated in battle") army in WWI.
    it was the jews who provoked hitler into starting deportation. it
    was the jews who made the US enter WWII, it was the jews, the
    jews, the jews. and then sit back and think about it all from a
    distance. try to get material not from the other side, but completely
    "unbiased", for example hitler's "mein kampf" or listen to his speeches,
    or those of göbbels. and look at how the war went, and what
    hitler said about "life space in the east", all these things, given
    directly by them. and then go back to the two versions of history
    and ask yourself what is more likely. that the nazis as the revisionists
    have a distorted view on races, jews, arians, world order or if the
    whole rest of the world is running a giant cover up.
     
    #27     Apr 4, 2007
  8. traderob

    traderob

    Man
    you finally wrote a lucid, pithy and well-reasoned post. Keep it up!
     
    #28     Apr 4, 2007
  9. man

    man

    do you know that one saying is that the undefeated german army
    was held back from victory in WWI by the politicians at home. in
    fact by the socialists. now think about it. just this little thing. how
    plausible is this? the army that fought for 4 years stands strong
    and is kept back from winning or at least getting a respectful
    draw by a politican? and forced into a horrible peace treaty? how
    unable to accept a defeat do you have to be to buy that?

    truth IMHO is that germany had become a super power in late 19th
    century, but lacked overseas influence. chancellor bismarck had
    carefully selected his opponents and allies. he was always interested
    in not getting caught in between the russians and the french. he
    knew austria was weak. and he knew england was the main
    german competitor overseas. the US were rising but no real force.
    then the german emperor, seeing all the new power and handicapped
    by a crippled arm while always running around in uniform to
    compensate for this, threw away all political intelligence of bismarck.
    and finally got rid of bismarck himself. now there were only the
    super self confident german generals, successful in war and the
    super productive and expanding german industry. here comes the
    20th century. everybody was armed big time. german's hunger
    for world wide influence growing and growing. everybody awaiting
    the big open wrestling.

    and all the rest is WWI textbook. german caught between strong
    enemies aside of weak alliencies. going back and forth, a draw
    after two years. at least it was clear germany could not win. stuck
    all over the place. US entrance making the final difference. and
    the german army was simply defeated. THIS is the real story and
    it has to do with global politics and not too much with races ...
    this came later on, with hitler and alike unable to live with the
    defeat.
     
    #29     Apr 4, 2007
  10. man

    man

    reread my last post. one thing is going to far. it looks a lot like
    german guilt for everything. which is not ture. before WWI the
    french very eagerly waiting for their 1870s defeat, the english
    were very concerned about german expansion, especially their
    ambition towards the sea. the russians were in between, they
    had had a very good relationship with bismarck but where quite
    concerned with him being away. but the russians had their story
    with the austrians, who were a weak, almost always losingInBattle
    giant, yet they were still around big time.

    the whole thing is international politics. as it always was, as it
    probably will be for quite some time.
     
    #30     Apr 4, 2007