Advice needed about top traders!

Discussion in 'Trading' started by UK2004, Feb 24, 2002.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. stevet

    stevet

    i love the fact that this nicholassegrue has not exhibited the slightest knowledge about trading - but everyone is eating shit to respond to his naive observations

    a classic and valid example of hype over reality - maybe we will get another internet type boom in the next hundred years - lets hope there are more nicholassegrue coming through and we can all get on another free ride
     
    #21     Feb 26, 2002
  2. amen
     
    #22     Feb 26, 2002
  3. UK2004

    UK2004

    Yes cocky, question for you, the other day it was announced that the underlying rate of inflation had risen to 2.6% and obviously rumours abound of an interest rate increase to reduce inflationary pressure, therefore we would expect the pound to strenghten due to interest rate differential parity and hot money inflows. However the pound weakened, why was this? My interest in trading is what led me to find out, I wander if you can tell me?
     
    #23     Feb 26, 2002

  4. This is something I'll address really fast.

    My father works with a lot of hedge fund managers, banks, independent traders and such. It is his experience that the worst traders are actually employees of a firm where they recieve very little compensation for their performance. Most of the types of jobs you are looking at fit in this category.

    What also caught my attention is your " wanting this so badly"but only until you are 25. It will take a lot longer to work to the top than 25. Most people under estimate what they can do in a decade or 2 and overestimate what they can do in a year. No firm wants to hire and train someone for only a year or 2 just to have them quit. Not when they invest a lot of time/money into someone.

    You can reach your goals but be prepared for quite a few roadblocks along the way.

    Robert Tharp
     
    #24     Feb 26, 2002

  5. A quote of that nature is coming from a perspective that the market's are completely predictable. If that were the case there wouldn't be a market. The top hedge fund managers tend to only be right about 40% of the time.

    Think about this question

    what if the markets were completely random and controlled by supply and demand.??

    Robert Tharp
     
    #25     Feb 26, 2002
  6. UK2004

    UK2004

    Trader 99 thank you for your polite response, interesting to see that he who has been in the field gives the polite comments.
     
    #26     Feb 26, 2002
  7. Nicholas..

    it seems to me that if your real desire is to own some other business, why waste your time learning to become a trader.. it would be like someone with no interest in medicine going to school for 10 years to become a brain surgeon so he could practice for two years, pay off his debts and have enough left over to open his own subway sandwich shop or something.. why not just pursue what you really want to do?


    -adam
     
    #27     Feb 26, 2002
  8. stevet

    stevet

    nicholassegrue

    in the interests in getting the internet bubble going again i will reply to your pound question

    money flows to the safest situation, in short, mid and long term horizons - so an indicator suggesting higher inflation, when the interest rate does not increase - is going to cause a negative reaction, as would a rising interest rate, unless it is combined with a benign outlook

    interest rates are a derivative of inflation, and inflation is a derivative of interest rates
     
    #28     Feb 26, 2002
  9. trader99

    trader99

    rtharp wrote:

    "This is something I'll address really fast.

    My father works with a lot of hedge fund managers, banks, independent traders and such. It is his experience that the worst traders are actually employees of a firm where they recieve very little compensation for their performance. Most of the types of jobs you are looking at fit in this category. "


    Nick, I think rtharp has a point here. Having worked on BOTH institutional sell/buy side of the biz, I can attest veracity of that statement. Performancces driven traders are usually the best. That's why hedge fund managers are usually the best(on average), because they don't get paid if you don't do well unlike mutual fund managers(earn for asset under mgmt) and i-bank traders who earn the spread.

    Look at the crazy internet funds that were set up after a grand 1999 bubble! Many of them are closed or folded into other tech fund. These people DON'T really know how to trade/invest. They were just there at the right time and place for the craziest bull market in our lifetime. Merrill Lynch's Focus 20 tech fund is down like 85%! WTF?! How come the guy didn't cut his losses at maybe 20%? Or at most 25%?!! I can't understand a fund being down 85%! That's beyond my conception of sound trading principle/money management.

    so, think about it.

    So, don't look down on these prop traders on these boards. Yes, they aren't managing a $100M fund or a few billions like Janus or Fidelity. And they aren't sitting on a billion dollar yen/dollar cross trades or $50M currency quanto options or inverse floater or $250M MBS IO stripps.

    BUT, they are doing a very important thing - learning how to trade in the market. And when you come down to it - that's what matters and what's going to be make you a good trader(if that's what you want to become). Most ibank traders are NOT what i would called "trader". They make a market - that's they earned a spread between the bid/ask.

    Here's an interesting stat for you to think about. In 1993, Citibank worldwide global currency desk made $300M profits. But $600M of those came from just earning the bid/ask. And the $300M was LOSSES from currency prop trading. Markets are difficult to figure out. Being a middle man is easy...

    good luck,

    trader99
     
    #29     Feb 26, 2002
  10. UK2004

    UK2004

    The reason for the pound not following market conditions was that due to the balance of trade deficit currently at an all time high in the UK the market did not feel the UK was ready for higher interest rates so they wouldn't appreciate the pound, as it would further damage exports, manufacturing in the UK is in dire straits at present.
     
    #30     Feb 26, 2002
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.