What makes you suspicious? Latency? Execution speed? Floating spread? Slippage? Or the absolute need to get all of these factors live-tested across different brokers?
I believe he showed an equity curve, but no sharpe / sortino stats....l to me, that is "telling". You've got to post one of the following: 1) sharpe 2) sortino 3) k-ratio
That's the way MetaTrader4 generates backtest reports. You've got a complete trade-by-trade report - now calculate all you wish.
Why don't you stay on T2W where allow this kind of b.s.? I have seen all your posts there. At least people do not seem to be asleep at the wheel here. They moved this out of the journal section.
It is pointless to discuss. Are you selling something? Is this service up and running? Are we not reading the same thread? Point to the number of posts here that are willing to try it or that think this is not suspicious.