30 minute bar trading using Grob/Hershey method

Discussion in 'Strategy Building' started by Dantheman, Sep 26, 2005.

  1. There are no trailing stops on level 1 .

    Tradestation code
    if T =1515 or t < 1500 then begin;
    buy next bar at h of data2 + .25 stop;
    sell short next bar at l of data2- .25 stop;
    end;

    if t = 1515 then begin;
    buy to cover this bar at close;
    sell this bar at close;
    end;
    if t > 1500 and t < 1515 then begin;
    buy to cover next bar at h of data2 + .25 stop;
    sell next bar at l of data2 - .25 stop;
    end;

    Today it lost $30
     
    #61     Sep 29, 2005
  2. I dont know anything about backtesting and I dont know anything about this system but just eyeballing the chart and the rules it looks to me like on an ES chart you were down about 8 pts. through bar four but dont you reverse long as the top of bar four is taken out by bar five which ended up netting about 4 pts as the rest of the bars are either inside bars or extensions?
     
    #62     Sep 29, 2005


  3. This is not the code for testing the MAK variation.

    YM vs ES

    Sorry, but I dont read anywhere that jack said it was only to be used on the YM.

    As to preceding conditions, none of those were mentioned by jack
    I tested his rules as he posted them.
    If you MAK can make money with this set of rules, that is a marvelous thing. Good luck with it.
     
    #63     Sep 29, 2005
  4. This is the way I see it but I may be misunderstanding something.
     
    #64     Sep 29, 2005
  5. An inside bar is inside relative to the previous bar, not to the largest bar in the "vicinity". Here are the trades

    835 S 1221.00
    930 L 1222.00 -50
    1005 S 1217.50 -225
    1045 L 1220.00 -125
    1135 S 1222.50 125
    1205 L 1224.50 -100
    1515 out 1231.75 362.50
    Net -12.50 b 4 commission
     
    #65     Sep 29, 2005
  6. chicken, with iteration 1 on the es today you should have been +3.5 pts before slippage and commission.


    hmmm i see you start and end your day 8.35-3.15

    that may explain it.

    9:30-4pm est got you 3.5 pts.
     
    #66     Sep 29, 2005
  7. Where do you see that qualification?
     
    #67     Sep 29, 2005
  8. tradestation "time" is at the end of the bar, so on 5 minute bars the first bar from the open is timed "835". This is exchange time, CST.
    I believe jack said it was ok to skip the first bar if one wanted to, but I included a trade from the open at 830 cst and hold/reverse till close at 1515.
     
    #68     Sep 29, 2005
  9. #69     Sep 29, 2005
  10. I mean in Jacks rules. Even doing it your way I still come out with a winner. What am I missing?
     
    #70     Sep 29, 2005