Not necessarily apples to apples, but tigerdirect has 36 reviews of the Hanns-g 19" wide screen. Reviews are very favorable. http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=1828823&Tab=11&NoMapp=0 For $120 bucks, if you didn't like it you could still sell it on Ebay for a profit.
19" screens with 1280x1024 resolution are useless as a trading monitor. Pay a little bit more and get a higher pixel count LCD. You won't regret the decision.
I got one last Friday. It's a bit bright for me, as are most of them these days, but otherwise good. Well worth $120.
Of course, but when adjusted for best picture, it was still too bright. Brightness could be reduced further but begins to look like being viewed through a dirty window. With best adjustment, it looks like being viewed through a lightly frosted window... lesser of evils, I suppose. But that's just my taste. I'm sure some people like excessive brightness otherwise they wouldn't keep making monitors brighter and brighter.