Why you generally suck

Discussion in 'Trading' started by longandshort, Apr 17, 2023.

  1. Good paper from NBER reviewing the performance of daytraders and their role of providing noise to the market. Day Traders, Noise, and Cost of Immediacy | NBER

    upload_2023-4-17_13-4-0.png
    upload_2023-4-17_13-5-8.png

    (page break hence redundant)
    upload_2023-4-17_13-5-57.png

    key takeaways:
    * aim not to be a noise trader -- trade on information or liquidity needs only (see another paper, the only game in town)
    * unless you're an ULL HFT, information precedes price -- find it and assess it before making a trade
    * trading the news is likely a fools errand
     
  2. Lmao. You are just a sample in my stochastic process. Muahahah
     
  3. TheDawn

    TheDawn

    Everything is noise in the grand scheme of things. Our whole entire life is just noise. The planet we live in is a tiny little noise in the universe and even the universe is noise in the whole multi-verse and I am sure the multi-verse is just noise in the bigger multi-verse.

    The reason why daytraders supposedly suck is not because they trade noise; it's because they are not good at trading noise. But then again nobody is good in trading. It's not like those big brokerage houses or funds don't lose money. LOL https://money.cnn.com/2017/07/18/in...-earnings-wall-street-banks/index.html?iid=EL I have seen value funds earning negative returns every single year and consider a 20% negative return one year as a good year. The fund manager even gave an interview on Morningstar advertising the fund. She finally resigned citing personal reasons after managing the fund for 23 years. LOL Two brokerage houses even went bankrupt after being in business for 100+ years, Lehman Brothers and Bears & Sterns. And look at Cathie Wood.

    Comparing to them, we daytraders are doing ok, much better as a matter of fact.
     
    Last edited: Apr 17, 2023
    alistera and comagnum like this.
  4. %%

    Dave ramsey noted 80% of IDT[individual day traders] lose money;
    i did not know that many made money=20%.
    The only 2 daytrading systems i saw that made money in hindsightLOL;
    the better one by far= made more money with less daytrades.
    But that was liquid markets +commissions , so overtrading because of no commissions may not be the best??:D:D
    Value funds have underperformed growth funds for so long;
    buyer beware of low priced junk, unless your name is mr Buffet, Goldblatt......:caution::caution:
     
  5. easymon1

    easymon1

     
    Last edited: Apr 17, 2023
    murray t turtle and TheDawn like this.
  6. TheDawn

    TheDawn

    I always thought MACD is pronounced "M A C D", each letters individually. I never knew MACD is pronounced "Mac-D". LOL Learning something new every day.

    But she's got the wrong MA for signals. It's not the 30-day MA you are supposed to look at; it's the 20-day MA. No wonder she was losing money. LOL
     
    rb7 and murray t turtle like this.
  7. KCalhoun

    KCalhoun

    The article is noise. :D
     
  8. destriero

    destriero


    Shouldn't this have been posted to the ES Journal?
     
    newwurldmn and longandshort like this.
  9. lmao, 1 easy trick and you too can be on your way to riches.

    :rolleyes::banghead:
     
    murray t turtle likes this.
  10. %%
    I think that's MCD, the hamburger king.
    30 is midpoint of 10+ 50dma, learning something new every day.30 days or 31 may mean much more than a line with 30 on it, but most anything is possible.
    Most people may never profit from Humble Trader, she adopted common sense[1] rule of not quitting your day job or [1b]not quitting your other business stream.
    8:30-3 CST public market is part time @ best.
    Hard to make part time when so many work full time; but most anything is possible.
     
    #10     Apr 17, 2023
    KCalhoun likes this.