Understanding P/L on a cross currency trade

Discussion in 'Forex' started by UVXY20, Dec 19, 2023.

  1. UVXY20

    UVXY20

    Ok, I'm using IB, looking over my trades for the years, and scratching my head over the accounting for a small May trade: I bought AUD/NZD for 1.05809 on May 25 for 25K US, which translated to 26,450.49 (with a two buck commission) and sold the next day for 1.07122 or 26,780.50 for a profit of 330.01 minus $4 commission.

    Ok, all good.

    But on the next line it says in USD I lost $290.04 plus commish.

    Details below.

    Educate me, please. I don't do much FX.

    Thanks in advance.

    AUD.NZD 2023-05-23, 01:18:19 24,998.34 1.05809 -26,450.49 -2.00
    AUD.NZD 2023-05-24, 16:40:22 -25,000 1.07122 26,780.50 -2.00
    Total AUD.NZD -1.66 330.01 -4.00
    Total 330.01 -4.00
    Total in USD -290.04 -4.00
     
  2. 2rosy

    2rosy

    what was value of USD vs aud on day you sold?
     
  3. Quanto

    Quanto

    Just a guess: maybe it means the USD was converted to the other 2 currencies..., and the result of the trade not yet back-converted to your USD acct. As said, just guessing as I've no experience with FX at IB.
     
  4. UVXY20

    UVXY20

    It was .6609 on the 23d and .06544 on the 24th. Ok, I gained 1.3 on the trade and lost 0.5 on the reconversion. That still doesn't add up. But even if it does somehow, how do I stop reconversion and just let it sit in the converted currency, AUD in this case. I just can't believe I actually lost money on this trade!

    Is this a good lesson in avoiding cross-currency trades and just sticking to FX futures?
     
  5. 2rosy

    2rosy

    you increase your exposure with 3 ways so the chances of catching something increases.