i want to buy one butterfly spread but it seems liquidity is not so good on them and they never fill in on the net debit I target (which is near the price it gives ) what would be better Spx spy or es
Can you give a live example of the spread and what the bid/ask is on the markets if you entered a market order and then what price you are looking to trade. Maybe your bid is just too low.
Traded options on all of those, but been doing SPY last couple years. Liquidity on most strikes for all of them, even fairly deep ITM is great I thought? You'll usually have to give a little better than mid tho on those spreads.
You are correct. Spy has narrow liquid spreads, but SPX is 10X SPY and has better tax treatment. A $0.01 spread is SPY is like $0.10 in SPX.
I look at the net credit of buying that butterfly but maybe it’s better to place them one by one and get a better price for al of them ?
You should enter spreads orders not try to leg. You need to calculate fair value for yourself and not use midpoint which can change with small customer orders. Then decide the most you are willing to give a market maker to enter the spread and enter an order a little lower than fair and move up slowly to your limit looking for a seller. The seller will be an automated MM looking for a little edge to their values.
I agree that it is liquid but market makers do not show their best bids and offers so it requires manually working your orders to find liquidity. And, I if lived in a different time zone than US markets, I would consider ES for the longer trading hours.
here is a trade i put in and it just doesn't fill already for one hour, a 4 leg trade with a net debit of 0.25 and just won't go