Is RSI better for intraday trading or swing trading

Discussion in 'Technical Analysis' started by cashclay, Aug 12, 2021.

  1. cashclay

    cashclay

    Just curious. I have started to look into the RSI and wanted some input. I am currently using the RSI at 14 day period. Do you guys think it is better to use the RSI for swing trading or is it better for intra day trading?
    And what day period do you use for RSI? I had heard that 14 might be to long
     
  2. maxinger

    maxinger

    OK. That's the straightforward question.

    Answer: None of the above.

    why? the market moves in various
    manner
    fashion
    speed / acceleration
    characteristics
    pattern

    Just delete the RSI and that eliminates the problem / question.


    Unfortunately, many people don't like to hear this answer.
    They insist and persist to use RSI, till the end of time.
     
    Last edited: Aug 13, 2021
  3. ph1l

    ph1l

    This book and this book suggest using half the dominant cycle period as the RSI period.
     
  4. kroxobor

    kroxobor

    Generally the higher timeframe the more reliable are technical patterns including signals from technical indicators. The downside of this that holding time can increase significantly since margin of error is high when you trading on high timeframes.
     
    comagnum and Nobert like this.
  5. sandy_s

    sandy_s

    I would like to double like your response.
    If you throw out RSI, there are dozen more which are there and few more which will emerge. Enough to keep retail traders busy trying to figure the best one out..
     
    maxinger likes this.
  6. VicBee

    VicBee

    I use RSI and other tech indicators because they look really cool on my screen and make me look seriously in the know (my wife laughs, my teen doesn't care).
     
  7. cashclay

    cashclay

    lol !!!
     
  8. cashclay

    cashclay

    really??? Do you use the RSI yourself?
     
  9. sandy_s

    sandy_s

    Good one!
     
  10. ZBZB

    ZBZB

    Relative strength to an index is infinitely better than RSI.
     
    #10     Aug 13, 2021
    comagnum likes this.