Help with SIG Interview Question about Options

Discussion in 'Options' started by DarkSkyParadise, Aug 22, 2015.

  1. Hey everyone -

    I'm a rising senior interviewing with SIG for a full time TA position. A friend shared a pretty basic interview question he got on options and was looking for some help. The problem is this:

    You have are offered a contract on a piece of land which is worth 1M 70% of the time, 500K 20% percent of the time and 150K 10% of the time. The contract says you can pay x dollars for someone to determine the land's value from where you can decide whether or not to pay 300K for the land. What is x? How much is this contract worth?

    In college options courses, I've learned the basic tenets of options - the option price is not the discounted expected payoff of the option. Also, the probabilities of the underlying asset moving up or down are irrelevant to the stock price. But, here the interviewer gives the probabilities. Are the expecting me to determine the payoffs and take the expectation? Or should I constructing a replicating portfolio using the asset and cash and find the price that way?
     
  2. Gambit

    Gambit

  3. garachen

    garachen

    Worth 529999.99

    If your time is free. And you like to make a penny.

    That's actually not a trivial question as the obvious answer is incorrect.



     
    Last edited: Aug 23, 2015
  4. garachen

    garachen


    Well, I guess the correct answer is also obvious.
     
  5. 2rosy

    2rosy

    How did you get this? Maybe i am coming up with the obvious solution 515
     
  6. xandman

    xandman

    I came up with that (or the full 815 prob value inclusive), too. It has to be wrong. It makes the 300K offer look silly low. We are solving based on cash flows which seem to be the right track, but I think the problem tests our basic understanding of optionality.

    I find this vexing. In RL, an assessment if $250 bucks.
     
    Last edited: Aug 23, 2015
  7. garachen

    garachen

    Yeah. 515 is the trick answer.

    Here's a hint. The answer would be the same if it's a 10% chance of being worth $0
     
    cjbuckley4 likes this.
  8. newwurldmn

    newwurldmn

    Its similar to the dice problem that they have been known to ask. You roll a die and get the payout (if you roll a six, you get $6, if you roll at 2, you get $2). How much are you willing to pay for this contract? The follow up is, how much are you willing to pay up front) for the option of rolling again?
     


    • $3.00 for each contract/roll
    • Maximum loss $2.00
    • Maximum gain $3.00
    • Risk:Reward 2:3


    :)
     
  9. newwurldmn

    newwurldmn

    Nope. You are wrong on the easy question. And didn't even answer the real question.
     
    #10     Aug 23, 2015
    samuel11 likes this.