Forcing Lawyers To Join Leftist Bar Associations Violates Basic First Amendment Freedoms

Discussion in 'Politics' started by ipatent, May 27, 2025 at 2:42 PM.

  1. ipatent

    ipatent

    Forcing Lawyers To Join Leftist Bar Associations Violates Basic First Amendment Freedoms

    The Supreme Court’s landmark decision in Janus v. AFSCME (2018) provides a step in the right direction for those facing compelled association. In that ruling, the justices recognized that compelling public-sector employees to pay union dues to subsidize speech they disagree with violates their First Amendment rights.

    The same principle should apply to attorneys forced to fund bar associations that engage in political and ideological activity. And while mandatory bar states generally have a mechanism to refund dues and allow attorneys to opt out of paying for overtly political actions, the reality is that this does not go far enough.
    ___________________________________

    This was a pet peeve of mine when I was practicing law. Bar associations that lawyers are compelled to join should stay politically neutral.
     
    Buy1Sell2 likes this.
  2. ipatent

    ipatent

    The same applies to teacher's unions.
     
  3. Republican administrations trying to force academic institutions to do what they want violates their basic first amendment freedoms.
     
  4. ipatent

    ipatent

    They're taking Federal money, that's different.
     

  5. Taking Federal money doesn't mean you must relinquish first amendment freedoms.
     
  6. ipatent

    ipatent

    No one is stopping them from speaking, Trump is just taking the funding away.
     

  7. They are attempting to restrict their first amendment freedoms by denying funding.Since thats not working they will resort to something else.
     
  8. newwurldmn

    newwurldmn

    I love this precedent.

    America gonna make Italy and India look like functional governments.
     
    insider trading likes this.

  9. upload_2025-5-29_3-33-33.gif