Finding a broker in Canada

Discussion in 'Trading Software' started by jim.thornton, Aug 3, 2016.

  1. I've been paper trading on TOS know for about 6 months. I really like it and have figured out how to use the software without issue. I can pretty much do anything that I need to do on it.

    In the meantime, I've been trading a small live account with Questrade. The platform isn't great, but it isn't horrible. Although, I think it would be WAY better if they just added the MARK PRICE into the column options when editing the columns.

    That said, I'm now looking at funding a live account. The Questrade commissions are just way too high in order to make it profitable. I am trading with TastyTrade style of trading so there are a lot of trades (usually 1-lots). I can get the job done with Questrade but the costs are just so prohibitive.

    I just downloaded the free trial for Interactive Brokers. I can't do anything in this software. I find it so difficult to use in comparison to TOS. Something as simple as entering a symbol requires me to type it in, click it, then a window pops up and I have to click it again. In tos, I just enter the symbol and press ENTER.

    That said, in Canada, the commissions for TOS aren't much better than questrade. In TOS it would cost $10 to open and close a 4-leg trade. In Questrade it would cost me about $15.90. In IB it would cost me MAX $8 (probably closer to $5).

    I know that IB can link into other software. Is there anything that I can get that is as easy to use as TOS? I'd like to get this new account funded by the end of the month, so if someone can suggest something, I have some time to try something out.

    I'm not opposed to spending a small amount of money on the platform, but the cost has to be MUCH lower than what I would be paying in the difference with TOS. Otherwise, I'll just spend the little bit extra on the TOS commissions and consider it my "Market Data package and Platform fee".
     
  2. I use Virtual Brokers. User interface is awfull. Rates:

    Per Trade - Commission Structure
    Equities: $6.49
    Options:
    $6.49 + $1.00 per contract (USD)
    $6.49 + $1.50 per contract (CND)

    $0.01 - Commission Structure
    Equities:
    $ 0.01 per share if share price ≥ $1.00
    $ 0.005 per share if $0.25 ≤ share price < $1.00
    $ 0.0025 per share if share price< $0.25
    Minimum commission is $0.01 and maximum capped to $9.99
    Options:
    $9.99 + $1.00 per contract (USD)
    $9.99 + $1.50 per contract (CND)


    I year ago I contacted TradrKing - they told me they plan to expend their service to Canada. Contact them, if they did, could be a good
     
  3. atrp2biz

    atrp2biz

    For any kind of trading volume, IB is the only way to go in my mind. I have no complaints. I also have BMOIL and TDDI, but w/o TOS for my buy-and-hold equity only portfolio.
     
    Last edited: Aug 4, 2016
  4. Virtual Brokers website shows they have $0.75 per contract with a $5.00 minimum.

    I don't think their Cust. Serv. reps know what they are talking about because they told me that it is $5.00 per LEG. Which would mean on an iron condor, there would be $20 in and $20 out of the trade. There is no way that can be right though.

    When you say the UI is awful, what do you mean? I just need easy one-click trades. Click on Bid to Sell and Ask to Buy of a spread with the ability to customize the trade.

    Beta weighting would be ideal too, but I can keep the Papermoney account for that purpose.
     
  5. What is BMOIL and TDDI???

    I wouldn't mind IB but I can't figure out their software and it seems like it is very cumbersome to use.
     
  6. atrp2biz

    atrp2biz

    Just a couple of the big bank brokerages. BMO Investorline and TD Direct Invest.
     
  7. Is there any 3rd party trading software at a reasonable price that can connect to IB's system?
     
  8. Gotcha

    Gotcha

    Have you looked at Sierra Charts? It has a very nice monthly fee and works with IB. Also, you should mention your province because it matters in Canada and not all provinces are represented by all brokers.
     
  9. Ontario.

    I will check out Sierra Charts.
     
  10. Gotcha

    Gotcha

    Gotcha. I have heard that in other provinces, like BC, some brokers don't operate there cause there are more rules.
     
    #10     Aug 4, 2016