It had not traded above 3.50 when you posted your 3.65 out. In fact, it's still not traded above 3.63, and that fill came nearly 10 minutes after your post. https://www.dropbox.com/s/i534ar5pl9ilfm2/2014-10-01_1013.png?dl=0
As of 1:15 Eastern: https://www.dropbox.com/s/ng1kuml06cnv54r/2014-10-01_1015.png?dl=0 Personally, I don't care as it was a decent call, but you should be up-front with the nature of each trade, whether it's hypothetical or actually taken.
Umm, the 3.63 didn't trade until ~10 minutes after you posted. 3.63 traded at 1:12PM ET. A two lot traded at 3.50 at 12:48PM. Another two lot traded at 3.63 fully 8-10 minutes after your post.
Your opening fill price is also wrong, the daily range was $2.80 - $3.12. Are you sure you got filled at $2.79? September 30, 2014 For a 1 day trade you should go with the weeklies.
He's now stating he got 3.63 a full 8 minutes before it traded 3.63. The only trade prior was at 3.50. Fantasy Island. Bye.