The ES appears quite predictable and rational with an after-the-fact analysis as some trading authors know, actually properly managing trades is...
Your post earlier implied real traders are legendary day traders who have for decades secretively profited continuously from market noise. I find...
Incorrect, if you define a strategy as following price-action setups. Al Brooks writes that even the best setups can fail ~40% of the time if I...
Institutional computer programs make up 85% or more of the volume and thus price direction of stock and future markets, HFT, makes up around 50%...
How do you know these hypothetical people exist? Aside from skill decline with aging and the evolution of the markets the longer a day trader day...
How come Al Brooks doesn't address this is in his trading books? Nothing on risk of ruin, total USD required per contract, average cost of...
Your earlier questions were red herrings. No. I purchased all three of Brooks' books on PA. Visaria's didn't say they profited on the 5 minute...
You're giving someone an opinion on Brooks and telling them not to listen to anyone's opinion on Brooks. That's not very logical or objective of...
Why would there be a bull side and a bear side, with the probabilities roughly 60-40 to 50-50 at all times if Brooks' teachings consisted of "the...
I never said "Al Brooks is a charlatan because he promises x and y occurs at a higher probability than x". My opinion that people that conflate...
How is making hostile accusations and blanket statements constructive on your part? Maybe Al Brooks isn't a charlatan for everyone, but he may be...
If NoDoji's reinterpretation and expansion of Brooks' seminal work is so sharply penetrating why is the weekly analysis video purely focused on...
I would get out as fast as possible If I was, as I do, use my AMP account's $500 per contract 6e margin rate. How much capital (USD) do you...
People who have been misguided by PA gurus are not trying to sell anything or prove that anything related to day trading works, even if something...
IMHO, ethical day trading instruction is ENTIRELY dependent on the teacher or author's successful execution of their teaching concepts and a...
Does the HFT on the ES futures market have any effect on day trader's trading? Studies say 46% of the volume on the ES is HFT but Al Brooks has...
With price action you can see the setups from a bullish and bearish perspective. Providing market analysis of each side would be much easier than...
You're suggesting that properly learning to quantify, as Brooks does, every detail on a 5-minute chart leads to consistent and scalable...
Does Brooks' explanation of all potential outcomes of chart patterns strengthen the case that Brooks is able to predict the outcomes of...
Is Al Brooks better...does Brooks show or write about how he has lost five, even ten trades in a row... such an event is determined to happen in...
Separate names with a comma.