You distill the difference very well. The only thing I will add is that there are several strategies/asset classes for which discretionary trades can be successful: risk arb, credit arb, and event driven all of which the fundamental decision can't be systematized.
Q Can completely discretionary traders every succeed? http://www.elitetrader.com/et/index...ly-discretionary-traders-every-succeed.53571/ What is your trading style? I'm a purely discretionary trader 76 vote(s) 32.5% I have rules and apply a little intuition 115 vote(s) 49.1% I trade my rules 100% 20 vote(s) 8.5% I'm a systems trader 23 vote(s) 9.8% UQ
I did a poll many years back and I was a little shocked that intuition trading was +15% higher than discretionary trading. I always thought it would be the other way around. That's a very large percentage of retail traders that are trading via gut feel (intuition). Extremely difficult to fix trading problems when they occur.
Manual traders fall into one of three classifications Mechanical - nothing subjective (this can be view as manual trading fundamentals) Subjective - widely aka discretionary - without firmly grasping the above.., this one is very hard to trade successfully..., this one is also what most gravitate to first Intuitive - need to be thoroughly competent at both above..., before this one even comes into play ============== Can one be completely discretionary (subjective)? No Mkt is uncertain...., completely subjective is also uncertain Two random variables..., working in concert - with the intention of achieving consistent results (which consistent results does not in any way infer / mean / equate to 100% wins) Will never happen..., never The best result will only ever be the boom / bust type..., which is self perpetuating / self re-enforcing Causing said trader to go on a quest - for another / better..., indicator / approach / methodology / signal / whatever (which won't work) ================================ Begin as a mechanical trader - learn the fundamentals - then move on.., or not - plenty of money can be made at this stage These fundamentals - are trading 101s Pre-define / know your A&M Enter each predefined signal (trade as the house..., not as a gambler) Make a trade plan for each trade - then trade the damn thing exactly Keep all / each losing trade small (never to exceed its planned SL) Allow all / each winning trade to make / reach its PT We never know which trade..., is which - until after the fact - so no need to act / think / trade - like it When one can do this in their sleep..., blindfolded..., with one hand tied behind their back - when healthy / sick / happy / pissed off/ hungry / or whatever - then..., and only then - should one contemplate moving to subjective Successfully assimilate subjective..., we can then discuss intuitive agree / disagree..., like it / dislike it - it is what it is RN
A&M - Approach / methodology A very clear..., simple..., and concise - A to Z document - of the what..., when.., where..., how - one is going about (approaching) their trading (the "why" best be to make money"..., the "who" would be the idiot clicking the mouse) Our approach.., tools..., signal(s)..., chart layouts..., when we trade..., we we site and observe - everything..., and anything - detailed out clearly..., concisely..., and precisely No bullshit..., no overly complicating crap..., no nebulous fluff One can't define it - either figure out how..., or eliminate it ================ Then we get to know it (internalize) - so when the shtf..., PA in a coma..., we get stopped "X" number of time in a row - we have a clearly defined process to follow After that - every trade gets its own plan Entry / entry signal SL / PT Way of managing and away we go..... In the mechanical stage..., no subjectivity is allowed - gotta get the fundamentals down stone cold first Then subjectivity can be introduced ========================== And if you're not sure.., examples of subjectivity: Cut losers short.., let profits run (short of what / run to where) BLSH / SHBL (and exactly what is hi.., or lo) Any momentum trade (no clue how far / long it will run..., or if its going to reverse just as hard and trap you) Anything not succinctly defined on paper - is subjective (even if it defined in one's head - we are human.., and humans are not robotic..., nor immune to life happens) RN