Why Do We Trade? For Real.

Discussion in 'Psychology' started by cornix, Mar 10, 2015.

  1. no worries - wasn't offended, just inquiring!
     
    #351     Mar 26, 2015
    StarDust9182 likes this.
  2. I think you have made some great points in some posts, but I am not interested in battles or taking sides one way or the other. Like everyone I believe some things about trading and disbelieve others but never think I know everything. If charting works for some people - great. More power to them. I even use selected charts for some kinds of trading. I don't understand having an issue with any method or any characteristic (even if true) of other traders. The markets have done far more emotional damage to me that any thread comments have. If all traders agreed on everything, there would be no trading or markets IMO. LOL.
     
    #352     Mar 26, 2015
    d08 likes this.
  3. Actually, wouldn't a trend indicate something inefficient about a market? After all, something that is predictive, is not priced in to the current price!

    This simple example has given me an idea for a new methodology and there is no TA involved in the idea. Thanks. I dealt with Martingale methods twenty years ago but there is always something new to learn by being open to other opinions.
     
    #353     Mar 26, 2015

  4. ok, point taken----- you should chat with Cornix about the market damage he has a website dedicated to this issue. Peace surf
     
    #354     Mar 26, 2015
  5. eurusdzn

    eurusdzn

    Hindsight can sometimes allow someone to look back at price and identify the day, the price bar, the catalyst, the news, the event that changed the price behavioir and marked the begining of trend.
    One example is the euro last summer broke 137-139 to the downside under the weight of deflationary data in the eurozone and expected ECB action. Nothing is certain easy and clear
    real time and price magnificatly reflects that by not instantly dicounting the euro to parity.
    How it gets there is unique in every instance but one can point to that behavioir and say
    "Thats trend".
     
    #355     Mar 26, 2015
    StarDust9182 likes this.
  6. kut2k2

    kut2k2

    The twisted logic is all yours, dude. You're the one who brought up the ten heads in a row (at least a dozen times previously). I show how to exploit it and now you want to pretend it's just luck?? LMAO! That is just so sad.

    I've already explained why this won't work for all random trends.

    And you've still yet to explain what this has to do with the nonrandomly generated stock markets.

    Again, care to revise your pathetically lame definition of trend?
     
    #356     Mar 26, 2015
  7. kut2k2

    kut2k2

    Please tell me you're not assuming the markets are as random as coin flips.
     
    #357     Mar 26, 2015
  8. IMO each individual coin flip is random, but the sequence of flipping is not a random process. It is very clear to me that the market is not a random event, nor a random walk in my experience. Therefore a trend can't happen in a single coin flip.
     
    #358     Mar 26, 2015
  9. VPhantom

    VPhantom

    Probably correlogram, a.k.a. autocorrelation plot in statistical analysis:
     
    #359     Mar 28, 2015

  10. Maybe it would be smart to actually run a correlogram on a stock market data set-- not directed at u specifically, but at those who have no clue.
     
    #360     Mar 28, 2015