Home > Tools of the Trade > Hardware > Earthlink DSL

Earthlink DSL

  1. I recently got Earthlink DSL but soon found out that
    it is extremely unstable.

    In the morning hours, I get disconnected many times. Not
    so much in the afternoon. When daytrading, this is extremely
    dangerous.

    Calling tech support is not much help, as all I hear is scripted
    responses such as check cable connection, keep computer 5 ft
    away, etc. Then they try to sell you products such as anti virus,
    firewall, etc.

    Is there anything else I can do or should I have gone with
    cable.

    Thanks
     
  2. I had ds"Hell" for a while.

    FWIW-in my case, I had 2 major issues that made the service unreliable.

    First, I had some bad connectors and a bad section of wire in my home phone wiring. Of course, the phone company could not figure it out, a neighbor who was at one time a phone tech fixed it for me.

    Second, I lived just beyond the maximum linear feet of wire from the Home Office ( I think this is 15000 feet.) even though the HO was less than a mile from my house.

    After struggling for about a year, I got cable and it is much better for me.

    DS

    ps-there are lots of people who have it and like it very much.
     
  3. I used E-DSL fo rmany years, it can be good, but I found that it interferred with my tel line and the cust svce as you have found out was very dissapointing.

    Cable is much better in terms of reliability and FASTER too!
     
  4. I have had Earthlink DSL (thru Covad) for years and liked it very much. I have cable as a back up and find that while the DSL may be slower for peak speed, its more consistent.

    The only time I had problems was when I had it on the same circuit as a window AC. When I moved it to another circuit, all disconnect problems ceased.

    Led me to conclude that DSL can be sensitive to electrical noise and/or sags.
     
  5. I also had EL using Covad as the ILEC for awhile after my previous ISP got out of the residential ISP business and handed me off to EL. No problems until one day my line went dead. Physically I had an SDSL setup because that's all my ISP had available when I ordered service but EL had my account listed as ADSL for billing purposes (EL SDSL service is big bucks).

    You haven't had "fun" with ISP tech support until you try to convince them that what they are looking at on their screen is wrong (SDSL uses different modems, doesnt share a line). EL tech support is strictly by the script, they can't/won't think outside the box.

    Anyway long story short - they werent capable of fixing it and after suffering through excruciating hold-times and incompetent tech support I searched for a replacement ISP with better ratings and came across Speakeasy.net. Been with them about a year now and can't say enough good things about them. They are not the cheapest (by far) but if you want to be able to speak to someone in tech support who really gets it (and speaks English as their first language) then I would highly recommend them.

    Judge for yourself:

    EL: http://www.broadbandreports.com/reviews/1050

    SE: http://www.broadbandreports.com/reviews/93
     
  6. I don't know if this helps but I had similar problems of service cutting out. after updating my router and changing the router set-up,it cleared up the problem I had.
    Also, you may want to go to www.dslreports.com. Many different forums there that can be of help. Also, diagnostic,speed tests,etc
     
  7. Thanks for the input.

    I continued calling tech support and using chat support but
    no help. It really isn't "tech" support, just
    check cables, phone lines, reset modem, etc. kind of thing.

    Went with Earthlink to keep the same e-mail address but
    probably should have gone with cable.

    Just can't daytrade with random disconnection. Too scary and
    dangerous.

    I will be moving soon, so will see how connection is with DSL.
    If still the same, then will go with cable.
     
  8. If you're moving, you might as well go directly to cable. Moving will probably mean cancelling your current plan and setting up a new one . Check with earthlink on this.
    Cable is much better than dsl and earthlink will probably offer their service through your new cable company.
    If not, and you still want your earthlink
    e-mail, they have a plan for only using(unlimited) e-mail for about $4-$5 a month. I currently use that with a non Earthlink ISP. No problem "receiving e-mail" through ISP but to send I have to connect using dialup.
     
  9. Depending where you are going I'd look into your local phone company's ADSL offering.

    The former Bell system local operating companies understand that the future is digital. I was speaking with a Verizon tech who was repairing a downed 200 pair local cable and he told me that they are all being retrained to think of "dial tone over DSL, rather than DSL over dialtone." Thus, they are/have switched the emphasis.

    I run Verizon DSL and a near T1 rate downlink and 368 Kbps uplink and it has been very reliable.

    Cable puts you on a party line and the more users in your locale the slower you will get, ADSL is a direct link to a phone company router.

    Jack
     
  10. I've been with Earthlink for many years and I'm quite happy with them. I did have some problems with random disconnects in the beginning, but it quickly went away after upgrading to a newer modem. I did replace the generic filters with the better quality ones.

    Good luck and happy trading :)
     
  11. Saying that cable is much better than DSL is meaningless and incorrect. Some cable implementations are better than some DSL implementations and vice-versa.

    As a generic technology cable's weakness is that it is shared medium at the neighborhood level while DSL gets you a dedicated circuit (and bandwidth) back to the central office DSLAM at which point your traffic is aggregated with everyone elses (e.g. you fight for bandwidth). With cable you are competiting for bandwidth sooner and if your immediate area is oversubscribed then you will feel it during peak periods. The downside with DSL is that it is very distance (and line noise) sensitive so many people can't get service or the service speed they want.

    My personal experience with Comcast (my local cable company) is that they have a television service mindset and do not take internet service outages very seriously and their support is spotty at best. Contrast this with an independent DSL ISP whose only business is internet service. Still as with all things the devil is in the details - research the specific cable and DSL choices for your new area and see what other folks are saying about them. DSLReports.com
     
  12. I have found that DSL is in general, more reliable than most cable systems: that is if you have a good dsl connection at your location