Would plain, straightforward answers to simple questions be more helpful?
I have several objections I'd like addressed but will hold them for now out of respect for the OP and his wish to debate them one by one. Still...
Are you asserting that SCT works with NQ?
What is this "science of trading?"
Great approach to thought reform. Bravo, Jack! http://www.workingpsychology.com/cult.html
Is that a rhetorical question? (To be perfectly candid, most of Jack's posts appear to be the textual equivalent of spilled ink. Of course,...
...does it to vent. Think about it, your mentioning of Jack Hershey name in this thread is an open invitation to invite trolls. You just...
Ah c'mon mark, be fair. If you can look for free advertising with your username (which the Mods didn't seem to like too much) and talk about...
Please remind folks why you didn't use the portfolios that the original author recommended, for the Nth time??? :cool: In case your memory is...
Show me where, in Jack's document (attached), that he said which portfolio to trade. He didn't which implies it works on all stocks, so I chose...
I don't know how backtesting works. It is something I am trying to get a handle on. The initial results formed a baseline for me. Idid figure...
...any trolling threads on ET, or anywhere else. 2) I like Jack Hershey, and he has always expressed a willingness to convey market trading...
Trade stopped out @ -2pts. (anticipated) Re-short @ 1414.00, PS @ 1416.00 FTT on 5 min time frame.
NOW, NOW (ie. pun intended, haha)! Tell the whole story T6. Your EQ curve, and this EQ curve. Your EQ curve was based on conditions that are...
I have not been trading it long, however I did sit with someone for the day and watched them trade SCT and he made a little over 12K for the day....
May I ask how long you have been successfully trading Jack Hershey's method?
We are just getting the facts straight! You chose a portfolio of your own choosing and not one that was recommended by the author of the original...
...anyone with an open mind everything they need to know about Jack Hershey's "methods" and his toady apple-polishers....
LOL - the call live trades tirade. I think see a short coming in the ES, c/o the Jack Hershey method. S @ 1411.50, PS @ 1413.50 JJ
Jack named his document "Catch Up with Tomorrow's Paper Today" and advocates buying the "0 to 7 shift" of the "P,V relation." Doesn't that imply...
Separate names with a comma.