
Forums (http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/index.php)
- Forex Trading (http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/forumdisplay.php?forumid=38)
-- trade the E-micro EUR/USD M6E ? (http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?threadid=240971)
trade the E-micro EUR/USD M6E ?
thinking this contract might be better than spot fx for Day-to-Days trading
specs: E-micro EUR/USD M6E CME/Globex 12,500 pip value: 0.0001 / $1.25
margin: overnight: $270.00 daytrade: $100.00
AMP rt comm: $1.99
Oanda margin: 12,500 EUR/USD @ 1.3150 leverage 50:1 = $328.75 margin
Oanda 'comm': spread @ $1.25 per pip
need to use Limit orders due to lower volume ?
You can use market orders if you want to hit/lift bids or offers
last I checked the micro contracts weren't liquid enough to even consider.. especially compared to spot.
They get a shot in the arm recently?
M6E for trading is ok( but a lil risky) if you don't have the money for the larger 6E contract but I would only trade it at its most liquid between 3am- 3pm Eastern(NY Time)
* I highly suggest keeping a chart or DOM open for the 6E to compare the price difference to the M6E so you can keep an eye on disparities between the two when it comes to the last price quoted
I wasn't looking to daytrade the M6E, strictly DtDs trades so I wouldn't be too concerned
about the fill price. Oanda's the largest fx broker and yes the volume of trades they
process is higher especially in the quiet times, however I thought I could more easily
open a second account with AMP for what I wanted to do rather than go to all the
trouble of funding an Oanda account
wanted to add AMP's minimum account size is $500 for the free NinjaTrader with the
CQG feed; see also margins, contract specs etc: http://www.ampfutures.com/
attached are the 6E and M6E 1min charts side by side and you can see the much lower
volume of the M6E, and, a much lower quantity of price bars later in the session -
140 v 116 , and similar price formation but not exact price matching
You are aware that the free Ninjatrader platform AMP is offering you is for charting and simulation only. If you want to use Ninja for live trading then you either have to lease it or buy a lifetime license.
Quote from southbeach4me:
You are aware that the free Ninjatrader platform AMP is offering you is for charting and simulation only. If you want to use Ninja for live trading then you either have to lease it or buy a lifetime license.
Quote from Wallace:
similar price formation but not exact price matching
Why don't you want to go with Oanda? Probably one of the best currency brokers for the price.
So 2.5 ticks spread on average + 1.75 ticks in commissions + questionable liquidity situation, that doesn't sound attractive to me. You shouldn't really pay much more than 1 pip per roundturn (spread + commission). If you are in the trade for a few days the transaction costs probably wont matter that much, i still dont see why you want to pay more than you have to.
Quote from Wallace:
I wasn't looking to daytrade the M6E, strictly DtDs trades so I wouldn't be too concerned
about the fill price. Oanda's the largest fx broker and yes the volume of trades they
process is higher especially in the quiet times, however I thought I could more easily
open a second account with AMP for what I wanted to do rather than go to all the
trouble of funding an Oanda account
wanted to add AMP's minimum account size is $500 for the free NinjaTrader with the
CQG feed; see also margins, contract specs etc: http://www.ampfutures.com/
attached are the 6E and M6E 1min charts side by side and you can see the much lower
volume of the M6E, and, a much lower quantity of price bars later in the session -
140 v 116 , and similar price formation but not exact price matching
Oanda:
noted for disconnecting the feed especially during the NFP release
do Not have a Trading Desk ???
sometimes refuse to close a trade !!!
which requires going thru the process of the security question being answered correctly
- remember yours ? - then the rep loading FXTrade entering your account # and closing
your trade
oh yes, and how long did you have to wait when you phoned to hear a live voice ?
what I - in theory - lose in M6E fills, I gain in lower margin and fixed commissions
@ 1.20 - Oanda's minimum, it's $1.50 http://fxtrade.oanda.com/why/spreads/recent
there's no slippage with a Limit Order, entry or exit
NinjaTrader:
the Chart Trader is the pop out/in Basic Entry order entry utility
personally I prefer having one that floats. among other problems with NT is the overly
large menus including the CT/BE. I have 2 NT charts loaded plus MT4 and one BE so on
one 17" crt screen it all takes up a lot of realestate, tho it's usually only the NT charts
I'm looking at when I've got a trade on, and the BE
the BE can be placed anywhere on the screen I want it whereas the paid CT version
it's on the right end of the chart and imo, inconvenient, although a user can still load
a Menu/File/New/Basic Entry instead of using the CT
If you already have a futures account, the M6E is clearly the better option than opening a forex account just to downsize your leverage.
Not to mention that forex brokers have a well-deserved reputation for corruption, data-feed manipulation, bid-rigging, stop-running, & many, many more nefarious practices.
If you think these practices are limited to a few off-brand, fly-by-night brokers, just search Google for CFTC's 2011 forex dealer lawsuits and reprimands. Virtually every major forex broker admitted to wrongdoing, several paid huge fines for corruption, and much litigation is still pending.
Why bother with it? Just trade Micro-futures, and be done with it. At least you'll be on a regulated exchange, where your orders are actually filled in a real market - not just bucket-shopped in a private transaction by someone whose business model is to screw you.
If you'd rather save that $1.50/RT to trade in a bucket-shop, go ahead. If you want to trade in the real market on a real exchange, then trade futures . .
Quote from Wallace:
Oanda:
noted for disconnecting the feed especially during the NFP release
do Not have a Trading Desk ???
sometimes refuse to close a trade !!!
which requires going thru the process of the security question being answered correctly
- remember yours ? - then the rep loading FXTrade entering your account # and closing
your trade
oh yes, and how long did you have to wait when you phoned to hear a live voice ?
what I - in theory - lose in M6E fills, I gain in lower margin and fixed commissions
@ 1.20 - Oanda's minimum, it's $1.50 http://fxtrade.oanda.com/why/spreads/recent
there's no slippage with a Limit Order, entry or exit
Quote from ddouglas:
If you already have a futures account, the M6E is clearly the better option than opening a forex account just to downsize your leverage.
Not to mention that forex brokers have a well-deserved reputation for corruption, data-feed manipulation, bid-rigging, stop-running, & many, many more nefarious practices.
If you think these practices are limited to a few off-brand, fly-by-night brokers, just search Google for CFTC's 2011 forex dealer lawsuits and reprimands. Virtually every major forex broker admitted to wrongdoing, several paid huge fines for corruption, and much litigation is still pending.
Quote from Jack_Larkin:
As for the commissions... this is where I think you're missing something.
In futures, commissions are charged on both legs of the trade, while Oanda doesn't do commissions at all and instead just quotes you a spread.
Lets assume the total spread on the micro futures is 1 tick (which we both know is not the case all the time, and often goes to 2 ticks even during liquid times of the day.) You're then paying your futures commission upon entering and exiting the market.
Now think about that.. your commission rate x2 plus the spread is your total cost. One contract's total cost at the best of times = ($1.50 x 2) + $1.25 in spread.... $4.25 for 10k euro exposure.
With Oanda, it's just the spread, they average 1.2 pips to 1.4 pips during liquid times, putting them at $1.3 for 10k euro exposure.
Always look at the total cost of trading... the difference here is huge, and that comes directly out of your pocket.
Margin being 50:1 with Oanda, that makes the amount required to hold a 10k euro/usd position ~$250 USD (it varies slightly on the exchange rate given the position is counted in Euro.)
You're not saving anything in commissions by going with AMP.
You're not getting better leverage by going with AMP.
M6E still has the issue with liquidity which will cost you more over time.
Quote from jo0477:
You are incorrect regarding commissions. $1.99 is the base rate/contract, RT - flat, all fees in. It is not charged x 2 as per your example. I believe this rate is fairly std for most brokers offering Micros.
Quote from Jack_Larkin:You're needlessly spreading fear.
Also, I've never seen a 1.3pip spread. I would NOT say that that's the industry standard - even for larger sizes. I opened a couple of small forex accounts a couple years ago - just to look into the whole situation, & 3-4pips would be a more typical average once you get past the ad-promises, & get to a live-platform feed. Granted, it's been a couple of years, but I doubt the industry has changed that much.
Besides, does a small spread matter if your broker can just re-quote you after the deal is done?
I have actually read the court filing on this racketeering bs case. It has zero substance.
Losing clients sue all the time. Futures brokers too, not only FX firms, you know. This is not specific to FX. Plenty of regulatory action against fcms too.
Quote from ddouglas:
Also, I've never seen a 1.3pip spread. I would NOT say that that's the industry standard - even for larger sizes. I opened a couple of small forex accounts a couple years ago - just to look into the whole situation, & 3-4pips would be a more typical average once you get past the ad-promises, & get to a live-platform feed. Granted, it's been a couple of years, but I doubt the industry has changed that much.
Besides, does a small spread matter if your broker can just re-quote you after the deal is done?
Quote from Pippi436:
1 to 1.5 pips after commission
Jack_Larkin: you need to pay a lot more attention to what you're reading before quoting
me incorrectly; and compare apples to apples instead of making up new numbers
specs: E-micro EUR/USD M6E CME/Globex 12,500 pip value: 0.0001 / $1.25
margin: overnight: $270.00 daytrade: $100.00
AMP rt comm: $1.99
Oanda margin: 12,500 EUR/USD @ 1.3150 leverage 50:1 = $328.75 margin
Oanda 'comm': spread @ $1.25 per pip $1.50 Minimum, for 12,500
and later
there's no slippage with a Limit Order, entry or exit 'no slippage' means there's
Nothing to add on to the 'cost' of the trade, I'm filled at That price
Oanda does Not have a Trading Desk
if I need to have a trade closed for me by AMP I have direct access to their Trading Desk
24 hours a day
suggest you read Oanda's own forum as well as here on ET to learn about discon-
nections, and also about people trying to close a trade, think there might also be a
thread about that too here on ET
Quote from jo0477:
That's not true. You get the standard version (or whatever It's called) free for live trading. You need the license for the ATM features, chart trader, etc.
Quote from stephan31:
----------
For any live trading Ninja is not free.
nope
peace
Hedvig
Quote from Wallace:
Jack_Larkin: you need to pay a lot more attention to what you're reading before quoting
me incorrectly; and compare apples to apples instead of making up new numbers
specs: E-micro EUR/USD M6E CME/Globex 12,500 pip value: 0.0001 / $1.25
margin: overnight: $270.00 daytrade: $100.00
AMP rt comm: $1.99
Oanda margin: 12,500 EUR/USD @ 1.3150 leverage 50:1 = $328.75 margin
Oanda 'comm': spread @ $1.25 per pip $1.50 Minimum, for 12,500
and later
there's no slippage with a Limit Order, entry or exit 'no slippage' means there's
Nothing to add on to the 'cost' of the trade, I'm filled at That price
Oanda does Not have a Trading Desk
if I need to have a trade closed for me by AMP I have direct access to their Trading Desk
24 hours a day
suggest you read Oanda's own forum as well as here on ET to learn about discon-
nections, and also about people trying to close a trade, think there might also be a
thread about that too here on ET
Interesting.
I'll check this out some.
peace
Hedvig
p.s. What are your rt's (static superdom) included for
FX Currencies
CL or QM
NQ
?
Quote from stephan31:
Interesting.
I'll check this out some.
peace
Hedvig
p.s. What are your rt's (static superdom) included for
FX Currencies
CL or QM
NQ
?
AMP does list a free version of NT on their site that has a bunch of features cut out.
Still, not bad.. and even if you had to lease it for the full feature set NT is one of the few platforms I'd say is worth it.
Jack,
Right. I only use a static superdom and charting.
No other fancy brackets/auto strategies, etc...
If being charged and extra .20 per rt--if one can lease Ninja for $60.00 per month--@300 roundturns per month then the extra .20 per rt is b.e.
Anything below that and one is saving money IF Amp matches a Ninjatrader commission quote from another brokerage.
peace
Hedvig
Just for fun, I took this screenshot from TWS at 2:36pm EST today: Full-size futures on the left, Micros on the right.
Edit: That's the bid/ask - I should have said that.
I just had a look at CME's micro contracts again. Apparently bid/ask-spread has improved since the last time i checked a few months ago. Looks like its mostly 1 tick now too, in the EuroFX atleast. Used to be pretty bad.
this argument about spread or slippage 'cost' is academic
Market orders can result in a +/- over/under the Last price/trade result depending how
the price may have jumped in the moments after the B/S/C button's been clicked
when a Limit order is used there's no spread involved, one's filled, or not, at that price
with lower volume one either accepts the Market order fill one receives or anticipates
the price and enters a Limit order prior to the price reaching one's order price
the same holds true for fx trades as well as the 125,000 size futures contracts
I've previously posted charts of price moves during the NFP release and when 'large'
orders have been filled. one never knows in advance if a large order's about to enter
the market and the result may see a 20-30 pip range on a 1min bar. I've also posted
a 12K+ ES trade during the last hour of trading that caused no price move except the
next price went 1 tick lower. but the price range can suddenly widen without a 'large'
order being the cause of expanded range. if one happens to have entered a trade at
such times then the result can be very good, or . . .
one thing about fx via Oanda I Will note is that one can trade via Oanda 24/365
but they're not staffed between the Fri C and Sun O
I'm writing this because at 12:30pm PST checking euro price I see in the Oanda MT4
there were a couple of trades made on Saturday, and from the 1.32145 Fri C, the price
has dropped 32 pips
the only problem I have with the 24/365 is sometimes there's a trade on Saturday and
sometimes not, so sometimes there's an 'extra' Daily price bar on the chart, as well as
there being a Sunday price bar
trades on these days of course go thru all timeframes
I suppose if you're a Gannist this doesn't make any difference since I believe Gannists
include weekends and holidays in their analysis, however my analysis is based on the
5 day trading week only, so I use an Alpari NY MT4 demo for analysis
regular Sun/Mon start time for Globex M6E is 3pm PST, errrr, or is it 2pm ???
AMP list 5pm as 'Exhcange Hours'
what I don't know and haven't tested is if there's any +/– difference between the 5 day
v 6/7 or 7 day trading week
price now down to 1.31754
It's a nice feature to trade over the weekend but most of the time it's not very advantageous to do so. There's often no movement, and when there is (interbank dealing starts earlier than 5pm EST on sunday so you can see price movement as early as noon EST) the spread is too wide (illiquid times) to make anything from it short term. It's not like you can catch someone's order sitting on the inside quote, the quote has to pass through your order, so the wide spread can't be captured either.
What's nice though is being able to enter or exit positions as the fundamentals change in the market. If a war action starts on sunday morning and you know your position will be slaughtered you can flatten out before the rest of the world wakes up.
just thinking about trading the M6E overnight, there is an 'excess' margin available
with which to daytrade
the Oanda margin to day or overnight trade 12,500 is $$328.75 , whereas the M6E
margin is $100 , so 3 x 12,500 contracts could be daytraded for $300 at $3.75 a pip
not sure if one has to close the trade first to access all the margin, or if being in a
new trading day the margin is simply available
Quote from ddouglas:
Just for fun, I took this screenshot from TWS at 2:36pm EST today: Full-size futures on the left, Micros on the right.
Edit: That's the bid/ask - I should have said that.
All times are GMT. The time now is 07:45 PM.