I think that is what they are telling you. Ask your self, I you were a successful trader, how much time would I spend teaching new people for 100's of dollars. The answer is zero. It sounds like you have an experienced guy willing to help you. This puts you ahead of 95% of this board. Treat his word like your bible and tune out everyone else. Think critically about what he says and try to make it work with your personality. But don't waste your time with Oscar's or anyone else's unsubstantiated claims.